Second look: Shazam! The Monster Society of Evil #2

I had previously wondered about the price point and format of Jeff Smith’s Shazam! The Monster Society of Evil (DC). After reading the second issue, I find myself caring about that stuff a lot less, because the introduction Mary Marvel has rendered me incapable of thinking anything grown-up or grouchy. She’s a delight on every level.

So is the book. The pace has picked up over the first issue, which results in Smith doing more of the things he does so well in the same number of pages. I’d almost forgotten how deftly Smith can lampoon human nature. Since this is a kid’s power fantasy, it’s only appropriate that he opens the issue with laughably dumb, thoroughly recognizable grown-up behavior.

I hadn’t forgotten how well Smith is able to render and dialogue adventure sequences. They’re a mix of scary, funny and exciting, and they’re peppered with small, character-driven touches. The book is such a great merger of words and pictures.

And it’s nice to see a creator able to fold dark undertones into a story without allowing them to flavor the entire narrative. Billy and Mary have both faced some bleak circumstances, and Smith doesn’t shy away from the perils the kids have faced or their emotional consequences. But he doesn’t make those moments so explicit or maudlin that they overwhelm the bits of triumph and giddy fun. If anything, the darker bits enhance the lighter.

And Mary is really awesome. To quote her or describe her behavior in any detail would be to spoil the fun of watching it all unfold, so I won’t. But trust me: awesome.

The shipping news

It promises to be another crowded Wednesday of comics arrivals.

The second issue of Jeff Smith’s Shazam: The Monster Society of Evil arrives from DC, as does the fifth issue of the second volume of Linda Medley’s Castle Waiting from Fantagraphics. Part of me feels like both of these would read better in collection, but that part is shouted down by the heftier portion that doesn’t want to wait.

I enjoyed reading the back and forth between comics retailer Alex Cox and Tom Spurgeon over at The Comics Reporter on the Shazam book’s appeal to young attendees of the New York Comic Con, and young readers in general, as it touches on a lot of questions that have been floating through my head. The first involved whether or not the per-issue cost of the series would be prohibitive for younger readers. The second centered on what quantity of casual readers made it into NYCC given the fact that tickets for some days sold out before the event began. (It’s probably incorrect, but I tend to place kids in the category of casual readers, in spite of how obsessed I was with comics from about age six and up. Maybe I just hope I was abnormal at that age and that other people have a healthier range of interests.)

Anyway, back to the ComicList.

The second-to-last volume of Chigusa Kawai’s subtle and surprising La Esperança ships via Juné. Maybe someone will hold hands with someone else in a non-platonic fashion this time around? It probably won’t matter to me if they don’t.

Viz has tons of stuff set to arrive. The battle of the stylists continues in the third volume of Beauty Pop. Suspense among obsessive sales figure watchers mounts as both vol. 10 of Death Note and vol. 13 of Naruto arrive on the same day. Which will emerge victorious in Diamond’s graphic novel sales for March? The first volume of The Gentlemen’s Alliance ┼ brings one of the weirdest casts I’ve ever seen in a shôjo manga set in a high school, which I find to be an unquestionably good thing.

Last and perhaps least from Viz is the fourth volume of Yakitate!! Japan. Don’t get me wrong. I like it in the way I like most quirky, young-men-with-a-dream shônen that has perhaps a bit more fan service than I like. But I’m starting to wonder if the bread-baking is making me overlook the fact that it’s… kind of average. (For those of you who’d like a shot at securing all four volumes in one easy shot, ChunHyang has thrown them all into an auction lot, along with some other tempting combinations.)

Six bucks

I’ve been trying to figure out if Jeff Smith’s Shazam! The Monster Society of Evil (DC) is worth six bucks, but I think I’ve been asking the wrong question. It’s not a case of it being worth that price point so much as whether or not it was smart to package it in such a way that the single-issue cost went that high.

It’s a quality object, with a sturdy cover, 48 glossy pages, high production values, and no advertisements. In the mathematics of comics production, all of those qualities push the price point higher, and I don’t think it’s just a matter of perceived value.

I appreciate the choice to eschew advertising, because Jeff Smith’s work has a purity and simplicity that would not sit comfortably next to greasy skater punks hawking yogurt in a tube or whatever other ads run in Big Two comics these days. It demonstrates a respect for the product even as it narrows the margin of profitability.

At the same time, this is a story that could and should be marketed to readers outside of DC’s traditional audience for super-hero comics. It’s by Smith, who has managed to appeal to both art-comics aficionados and a mainstream audience with his deservedly beloved Bone series. The finickiest connoisseur can appreciate the craft of Smith’s work while the reader picking up a graphic novel for the first time can get lost in the story.

And that’s basically what Smith does with Shazam! There are no barriers to entry into the world of the story; you don’t need any familiarity with the character to appreciate the story of a hard-luck kid being rewarded for his decency and thrown into a fantastical world of legendary heroes and bizarre monsters. It’s fun and imaginative and a little scary, and it looks great.

But I do wonder if the price tag will be an obstacle that keeps casual readers – who’d really enjoy it – from picking it up. It’s a general-audience story with Direct Market packaging and pricing, and those qualities seem to be in conflict.

On the one hand, DC seems to be dancing with the ones who brought them with a package that sits right at the top of the quality scale for single-issue publishing. And the price issue will probably be moot when the inevitable collections (hard- and soft-cover) come into play, because this is the kind of story that could reasonably be expected to fly off of bookstore shelves and go into heavy library circulation.

And really, the book is right in line with what a number of pundits have been begging for – a fun take on an iconic character that isn’t yoked to continuity or a self-consciously “mature” corporate tone. I’m sure that DC is perfectly well aware that the series of individual issues won’t reach its broadest potential audience and that they’re trying to maximize profits from all of its published iterations. That’s a sensible thing for a publisher to do, no matter how taken I am with the loss-leader model of anthologies or web-to-print.

So I guess the question I’m really asking is whether or not I’m willing to pay six bucks per issue.

Grab bag

Stop it, manga! I haven’t received my tax refund yet! And you, western comics publishers… you’re not helping! At all!

Tons of the stuff that was due out last week is actually arriving this week, along with a bunch of other stuff that I want. It’s going to be a bloodbath.

The first culprit is Dark Horse, which unleashes new volumes of Eden: It’s an Endless World!, Mail, and The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service, any one of which could vie for “pick of the week” status. I’m also very curious about the first volume of Red String by Gina Biggs, the first volume of a collection of a shôjo-influenced webcomic.

I can’t remember the last time I was really excited by the prospect of a monthly from DC, but I’m really looking forward to Shazam: The Monster Society of Evil. My interest in the character probably peaked with the live-action Saturday-morning show that ran when I was about eight (and even then I preferred Isis), but it’s Jeff Smith doing a comic that doesn’t apparently require consumption of an anti-depressant to get through it. It sounds like exactly the kind of friendly-to-a-wider-audience treatment of an iconic character that some bloggers have been wanting.

And Dark Horse doesn’t own the helping-the-dead manga category this week. CMX has a new volume of Omukae Desu.

I remember reviewing the first two volumes of Category: Freaks (DrMaster) about a year ago, and the third volume is just coming out now? I’ll have to put it on the “check it out when time and disposable income permit” list.

Escape from “Special” by Miss Lasko-Gross (Fantagraphics) will also go on that list. It sounds intriguing, and who can resist exuberant, demographically sensitive solicitation text like this: “Miss Lasko-Gross, who has the sensibility of a love child of Linda Barry and David B. midwifed by Judy Blume, has created a graphic novel that should appeal not only to the growing readers of graphic novels, but to teens grappling with similar unresolved questions.” Not me, that’s for sure.

Oni releases the second issue of the very appealing Maintenance, a workplace comedy about custodians at a mad-scientist think tank.

Viz delivers the Shojo Beat titles that were initially scheduled for release last week, along with the final volume of Train Man: Densha Otoko, my favorite of the competing manga adaptations of the story.

BAMmage

The local Books-A-Million is having a buy-two-get-one-free sale on Dark Horse and DC trades, including the Absolute editions from DC. I’m guessing it’s chain-wide (there were official-looking stickers and everything), so you could save a nice chunk of change if you had some of those books on your shopping list.

Truth, justice, etc.

Mely relates an irritating instance of customer service and the depressing issues that swirl around such encounters with surgical precision:

“The thing is—I know the people who most need to hear this probably aren’t going to listen anyway, but I was trained early in childhood to argue with brick walls—the thing is, when someone insults my taste or my intelligence or my entertainment, when someone dismisses something I like as commercial or trashy or dumb or unworthy of attention, when someone announces that my interest in manga is only important as a stepping stone to the holy grails of alt comics or the pockets of DC and Marvel—strangely, this does not make me rethink my tastes.”

There’s fabulous stuff in the comments as well.

Lyle wonders if Chuck Dixon is the right writer for a Midnighter series, given the character’s sexual orientation and what one might charitably call the creator’s ambivalence towards it. Loren at One Diverse Comic Book Nation and Johanna at Comics Worth Reading weigh in as well.

And at Yet Another Comics Blog, Dave Carter is sponsoring his annual Comic Book Legal Defense Fund Fund Drive.

Moto shôjo mojo

Dirk Deppey points to a ComiPress blurb on Moto Hagio, who received an award for Otherworld Barbara, her most recent work. I seem to be in a mode where I really can’t shut up about Hagio, even though I’ve only read one of her works (A, A1).

Anyway, all of the recent discussion about DC’s new Minx line and its efforts to attract teen girls got me thinking about what I’ve read about the evolution of shôjo and some of the events that turned comics for girls into a creative and commercial force in Japan, so I tried to put those thoughts into some coherent form for this week’s column. I don’t think I was entirely successful, but that’s never stopped me before.

And it gave me another chance to beg for a translation of Rose of Versailles.

Eye candy

Four things of beauty for the day:

  • Bryan Lee O’Malley offers his take on Hope Larson’s Salamander Dream.
  • MetroKitty assembles brilliant collages of the clenched fists and parted lips of Essential Tomb of Dracula.
  • John Jakala shares a page from Tintin Pantoja’s pitch for a manga-influenced Wonder Woman.

The suspense is killing me!

Well that was a pleasant surprise. I thought NBM was only shipping a new printing of Rick Geary’s The Borden Tragedy, but a copy of the paperback version of The Case of Madeleine Smith showed up in my reserves yesterday. New installments of A Treasury of Victorian Murder are always gratefully accepted.

Speaking of the accused Glaswegian, she’s made her way onto the list of nominees for the American Library Association’s Great Graphic Novels for Teens. (Yes, I’m still obsessively tracking those. Thanks for asking.) Nominations are now closed with a projected drop date for the final list in mid-winter of 2007.

It’s a little hard to tell what joined the list when, but accounting for my shaky memory, recent additions include:

  • Action Philosophers: Giant-Sized Thing #1 (Evil Twin)
  • American Born Chinese (First Second)
  • Brownsville (NBBComics Lit)
  • Chocalat (Ice Kunion)
  • Crossroad (Go! Comi)
  • Fables: 1,001 Nights of Snowfall (Vertigo)
  • Infinite Crisis (DC)
  • Inverloch (Seven Seas)
  • The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service (Dark Horse)
  • Livewires: Clockwork Thugs, Yo! (Marvel)
  • Pride of Baghdad (Vertigo)
  • Same Cell Organism (DMP)
  • To Dance: A Ballerina’s Graphic Novel (Simon and Schuster)
  • Young Avengers Vol. 2: Family Matters (Marvel)

I hope the nomination list is still available after the final roster is chosen, because there are some great books on it. But barring some bizarre failure of decision-making, it’s hard to see how the final list could be anything but excellent.

(Edited to note: If I missed anything new to the nominations, let me know, and I’ll add it to the list.)

Minx in Chief

Newsarama’s Matt Brady interviews DC’s Karen Berger about Minx. Berger provides additional detail on some of the titles and the philosophy behind the line.

“There’s no one out there, when you think about it, doing a line of graphic novels for teenage girls. You have manga, but it’s import and, while there’s a lot of really great stuff, it’s not fully for teenage girls.”

Discounting the heavily branded Shojo Beat.

“Scholastic has a few titles, but those are skewing younger or older. No one is really attacking this area in a full-fledged way with a major imprint, and we’re doing it.”

And I suppose it’s true that, while Tokyopop’s global books do feature a number of teen-girl-friendly stories, Tokyopop has always resisted the kind of categorization that Viz employs (Shojo Beat, Shonen Jump, Signature, etc.). She never actually mentions Tokyopop, though perhaps there might be some coded references:

“We’re not bringing in manga storytelling devices, we’re telling clear straightforward stories in a way that we feel they should be told, but we’re not adapting any manga. We’re looking at this as an alternative to manga – as an alternative to young adult fiction – we’re trying to find a new area of contemporary fiction.”

Consider me torn. I would like for this line to succeed, because more good comics for young adult readers always makes me happy, and in spite of the fact that I’m staring 40 square in the eye, I tend to like a lot of the comics already available for young adult readers. I’m glad that DC finally decided to engage this audience in a serious way and handed the enterprise to people who, as Warren Ellis put it, are “more curatorial than editorial.” And the quality of the talent attached certainly seems to bear that out; I’m genuinely excited by the possibilities of the books.

But there’s just something about the way it’s being framed that’s making me stompy. Tons of publishers have released great material for this audience, whether original or licensed. Stamping “Minx” on it and hiring a marketing firm doesn’t make it new, no matter how shrewd the execution.