The Manga Curmudgeon

Spending too much on comics, then talking too much about them

  • Home
  • About
  • One Piece MMF
  • Sexy Voice & Robo MMF
  • Comics links
  • Year 24 Group links
You are here: Home / Archives for Linkblogging

Manga 101

June 17, 2009 by David Welsh

One of those random bits of curiosity has taken root, and I might try and get a column out of it if I can find sources. So, does anyone know of any folks who are teaching or have taught introductory manga courses at the college or university level? I’m thinking primarily of survey courses rather than ones that focus on creating comics. If you know of anyone, or if you’ve taught such a course yourself, drop me a line.

manga_60yearsI think if I were constructing a course like that, I would probably use Paul Gravett’s Manga: Sixty Years of Japanese Comics as the primary text. I like the book’s structure, and I think it provides a great overview of the history and various demographic categories. It’s also packed with illustrations from all kinds of titles (including a rather energetic hamster-like creature that got the book banned in Victorville, California).

The reading list would be tricky. I would want to include examples from the major demographic categories (shônen, shôjo, seinen, josei), but I think I’d have to be careful to find stuff that’s representative but doesn’t end up in a cripplingly expensive trip to the bookstore. That would mean picking titles that give a reasonable amount of story in a single volume but still do a good job embodying certain common traits about the category. I’d probably just plan on taking whatever lumps come in the form of complaints about not getting the full story. (I could always include a paragraph on the syllabus that gives the total price tag for complete series included on the reading list; some of the best examples are really long, and even if the price of individual volumes isn’t that high, when you ask someone to buy twenty of them…)

I’d also want to include works by the greats, particularly Osamu Tezuka. That gets a little tricky too, as I’d want something relatively accessible. Astro Boy seems like a reasonable enough choice in terms of accessibility (and Dark Horse offers this two-volume paperback), though I’d much rather have them read something like Ode to Kirihito. Since there’s so little of the work from the Year 24 Group available in print and in English, I’d turn to Vertical for To Terra… (I know it isn’t shôjo, but it’s a great book, and it provides an early example of a woman creating comics targeted at boys, which seems like an interesting teachable moment.)

I’d probably leave anime to the film studies program, or whatever those units are called these days.

So what would you include on your reading list?

Update: Speaking of manga scholarship, Simon (NSFW) Jones finds an interesting piece on international demand for a National Center for Media Arts.

Filed Under: Flipped, Linkblogging, Wishful thinking

Link of the day

June 11, 2009 by David Welsh

Someone’s probably already linked to this, perhaps repeatedly, but I came across it when I was doing some research for another piece, and I thought it was fascinating. It’s the text of noted shôjo scholar Matt Thorn’s presentation, “The Multi-Faceted Universe of Shôjo Manga.”

Anything that starts with a sampling from the translated script of Moto Hagio’s The Heart of Thomas has to be good, and this certainly doesn’t disappoint, looking at the history of the category, its current state, and the future. Money quote:

“In a digital world, female artists who have been restricted for decades by male editors who think they know best what female readers want, will find a very different landscape. We have only glimpsed the borders of that Undiscovered Country, and it will no doubt be a harsh frontier. Many artists, accustomed to the old ways, will no doubt follow the printed magazine and the publishing dinosaurs to extinction. But others will surely make their way and create a place for themselves where they can connect directly with their readers, without worrying about whether or not their work ‘adheres to editorial policy.’ You can get a taste of what that Brave New World might look like if you attend one of the hundreds of comic markets held across Japan every year. There you will see vast gatherings of women—in some cases, tens of thousands—buying and selling self-published manga, utterly free of editorial constraint.”

Filed Under: Linkblogging

Nomenclature

June 10, 2009 by David Welsh

How long has ICv2 been using “traditional graphic novels” to describe everything that isn’t manga? I’m not quite sure what to make of that.

Filed Under: Linkblogging

Upcoming 6/10/2009

June 9, 2009 by David Welsh

This week’s ComicList is on the lean side, but there are a couple of items that are worth scrutinizing.

colorofwaterOne is Kim Dong Hwa’s The Color of Water (First Second), the second part of his trilogy that began with The Color of Earth. I’ve read both in the form or preview copies provided by the publisher, but I’ve been a bit stymied when I’ve tried to sit down and actually write about them. They’re great-looking books; I very much admire the visual style. But I find the content a little off-putting, though I’m not sure I have the right to voice these particular objections.

The Color books compose a period piece that traces the sexual comic of age of a young girl in rural Korea. It’s an experience and a transition that the creator clearly reveres, but for me, it was an uncomfortable kind of reverence. It’s reverence with a degree of distance that seems to flatten and simplify the experience being rendered; the path from girl to woman is dewy and magical, uncomplicated and pristine, or at least that’s the impression the books left. I feel like it crosses the line between celebratory and condescending.

The crew at Good Comics for Kids participated in an illuminating roundtable on the first book, and I was relieved to see my concerns articulated in the discussion. There are also persuasive arguments in the book’s favor, but I’m still unconvinced that its merits overcome its underlying tone.

dmcI’m fairly sure my reaction to the week’s other big release, Kiminori Wakasugi’s Detroit Metal City (Viz), will be much less complicated. I will either be overcome with guilty love, or I’ll be grossed out. I’m reassured by Kate (The Manga Critic) Dacey’s assessment, though:

“I’d be the first to admit that DMC walks a fine line between clever and stupid with its raunchy lyrics and outrageous concert scenes, but it never wears out its welcome thanks to a great cast of characters.”

We’ll see.

Filed Under: ComicList, First Second, Linkblogging, Viz

Just curious

June 1, 2009 by David Welsh

I was reading this item over at Robot 6, and my experience (limited as it is) tracks with James Sime’s… most comic shops I’ve frequented aren’t typically open on Mondays. I threw the question out on Twitter, and most people said their local shops did have Monday hours, but I still thought I’d up a quick poll.

Filed Under: Linkblogging, Polls

Go. Read. Now.

May 13, 2009 by David Welsh

Writing for ComiPress, Lawrence A. Stanley provides a comprehensive overview and analysis of the prosecution of Christopher Handley for possession of obscene images:

“It is often said that ‘bad cases make bad law,’ but here the bad law is being made by legislators and judges alike who climb over each other in an effort to prove their moral uprightness and supposed concern with protecting children.”

Over at MangaBlog, Brigid Alverson considers the chilling implications:

“This case is frightening on a number of levels: The eagerness of state and federal authorities to invade someone’s privacy for a victimless crime (remember, we’re talking about drawings here), the disregard of the constitutional rights to privacy and freedom of speech, and the government’s treatment of Handley, which reads like something out of a dystopian novel.”

Filed Under: Linkblogging

Wednesday poll

May 6, 2009 by David Welsh

Over at Comics Worth Reading, Ed Sizemore takes a look at the The Society for the Promotion of Japanese Animation Industry Awards Ballot and makes some interesting, genre-centered suggestions on what a manga awards could look like. Over at About.Com, Deb Aoki rounds up a nice list of titles that could have fit in nicely in a number of Eisner Award categories.

Since the notion has been in the back of my mind lately, I thought I would throw out a quick poll on one structural aspect of a possible manga awards program.

Filed Under: Awards and lists, Linkblogging, Polls

Free Comic Book Month underway at YACB

May 2, 2009 by David Welsh

Dave (Yet Another Comics Blog) Carter is holding his fifth Free Comic Book Month giveaway! What’s it all about?

“Each day of May [Dave will] pick someone to receive a free comic, taken from [his] personal collection: duplicates, things [he has] in trades, and other stuff. [His] goal is to match up people with a comic that they haven’t read but that they may like. [His] tastes are wide and varied, so chances are [he has] a comic for you.”

It’s like the twelve days of Christmas, but longer and with comics instead of disease-ridden birds and high-maintenance performers!

Filed Under: Contests and giveaways, Linkblogging

Yaoi Press hit by flooding

May 1, 2009 by David Welsh

Yaoi Press has lost a lot of stock to flooding just prior to Anime Central. Tina Anderson has the details, and points to an auction that can help the publisher out during a really tough time. You can also check out Yaoi Press titles on the Netcomics site for a quarter a chapter, and you can keep up with the situation on the publisher’s Twitter feed.

Filed Under: Linkblogging, Yaoi Press

Liza's greatest hits

April 30, 2009 by David Welsh

I’m sad to hear about Liza Coppola’s departure from her role as Viz Media’s Senior Vice President for Sales and Marketing. I’ve always enjoyed reading interviews with her and admired her insights on the comics industry and her frankness. Here are some examples:

2007 interview with ICv2:

  • Part 1
  • Part 2
  • Part 3
  • 2005 interview with ICv2:

  • Part 1
  • Part 2
  • Part 3
  • Part 4
  • Filed Under: Linkblogging, Viz

    « Previous Page
    Next Page »

    Features

    • Fruits Basket MMF
    • Josei A to Z
    • License Requests
    • Seinen A to Z
    • Shôjo-Sunjeong A to Z
    • The Favorites Alphabet

    Categories

    Recent Posts

    • Hiatus
    • Upcoming 11/30/2011
    • Upcoming 11/23/2011
    • Undiscovered Ono
    • Re-flipped: not simple

    Comics

    • 4thletter!
    • Comics Alliance
    • Comics Should Be Good
    • Comics Worth Reading
    • Comics-and-More
    • Comics212
    • comiXology
    • Fantastic Fangirls
    • Good Comics for Kids
    • I Love Rob Liefeld
    • Mighty God King
    • Neilalien
    • Panel Patter
    • Paul Gravett
    • Polite Dissent
    • Progressive Ruin
    • Read About Comics
    • Robot 6
    • The Comics Curmudgeon
    • The Comics Journal
    • The Comics Reporter
    • The Hub
    • The Secret of Wednesday's Haul
    • Warren Peace
    • Yet Another Comics Blog

    Manga

    • A Case Suitable for Treatment
    • A Feminist Otaku
    • A Life in Panels
    • ABCBTom
    • About.Com on Manga
    • All About Manga
    • Comics Village
    • Experiments in Manga
    • Feh Yes Vintage Manga
    • Joy Kim
    • Kuriousity
    • Manga Out Loud
    • Manga Report
    • Manga Therapy
    • Manga Views
    • Manga Widget
    • Manga Worth Reading
    • Manga Xanadu
    • MangaBlog
    • Mecha Mecha Media
    • Ogiue Maniax
    • Okazu
    • Read All Manga
    • Reverse Thieves
    • Rocket Bomber
    • Same Hat!
    • Slightly Biased Manga
    • Soliloquy in Blue
    • The Manga Critic

    Pop Culture

    • ArtsBeat
    • Monkey See
    • Postmodern Barney
    • Something Old, Nothing New

    Publishers

    • AdHouse Books
    • Dark Horse Comics
    • Del Rey
    • Digital Manga
    • Drawn and Quarterly
    • Fanfare/Ponent Mon
    • Fantagraphics Books
    • First Second
    • Kodansha Comics USA
    • Last Gasp
    • NBM
    • Netcomics
    • Oni Press
    • SLG
    • Tokyopop
    • Top Shelf Productions
    • Vertical
    • Viz Media
    • Yen Press

    Archives

    Copyright © 2026 · Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in