'tis the season, apparently

Robot 6 has pointed to some early “Best of 2009” lists, one from Publishers Weekly and another from Amazon. Just like Christmas advertisements, it feels like best-of season is starting too early.

And just because it’s Monday and I’m in something of a grumpy fog (because one of my dogs marked our return from a weekend away by waking us up every hour on the hour), I feel the need to make a provocative remark. As much as I admire Yoshihiro Tatsumi’s A Drifting Life and recommend it, 2009 was (in my opinion) a spectacular year for new and ongoing series. So while I would certainly put A Drifting Life in my top ten, I don’t think it would rank first.

Update: Over on Twitter, Danielle (Manga Before Flowers) Leigh says what I meant: “I think Drifting Life is the most *significant* manga published, but not the all-round “best””

Update #2: The final roster of nominees for the 2010 Great Graphic Novels for Teens list is up over at the Young Adult Library Services Association’s web site.

Recent reading

Interesting things I’ve read lately:

A roundtable on digital piracy of comics featuring representatives of Fantagraphics, Dark Horse and Top Shelf: It kind of surprises me that Aaron Colter from Dark Horse never mentions the impact of piracy on the publisher’s licensed products, though it doesn’t surprise me that Fantagraphics experiences more piracy in its Eros line, a lot of which is translated product from Japan. I sometimes suspect that respect for a creator’s rights doesn’t always extend beyond one’s continent of residence, or it at least loses some of its ideological vigor.

Musings on the National Book Award categorization of David Small’s Stitches over at NPR’s Monkey See blog: This is a curious turn of events. I admire the book a lot, but I don’t think the hubbub over its nomination does it any favors, though it obviously doesn’t diminish Small’s achievement. As Tom Spurgeon has said so often, book publishing is gross. (And I also wanted to note that the Monkey See blog is generally a lively, entertaining read. I’ve been enjoying its comics content, though I hope Glen Weldon writes about manga at some point.)

The Robot 6 coverage of the Big Apple-New York Comic-Con situation by Sean Collins: The actual outcome of this is really only interesting to me in the abstract, because I’m unlikely to attend either event, much less both, but Collins approaches the subject with wry thoroughness.

A story at Publishers Weekly that provides some clarification on those Federal Trade Commission guidelines for blogger disclosure: Well, “clarification” is probably as optimistic a term as “guidelines,” but the story makes the guidelines seem less draconian. Or at least it presents the comforting notion that the FTC has no idea how to enforce the guidelines, if and when they figure out what those guidelines actually are.

Time is running out

The list of nominations for the 2010 Great Graphic Novels for Teens has been updated over at the Young Adult Library Services Association’s site. October is the last month to nominate a title. Anyone can nominate a book, as long as they aren’t the creator or publisher of the work, and the book needs to have been first published between Sept. 1, 2008, and Dec. 31, 2009. Click here to nominate something. It’s easy!

The current decade

Over at The Comics Reporter, Tom Spurgeon is assembling a roster of works to consider for the Best of the Decade, 2000 to 2009. Go take a look, then send Tom your own suggestions. The starter list is already amazingly formidable.

What happens in Vegas…

… has nothing to do with what’s about to happen in San Diego at the 2009 Comic-Con International, except for the fact that I might actually go if it were happening in Vegas. I love comics, I really do, and there are some great-sounding panels and activities (which I cherry pick in this week’s Flipped), but I can’t see taking a plane and everything that entails just for a comics convention. I’m going to SPX this year, but that’s an easy and pleasant drive for me to one of my favorite metropolitan areas. If CCI moved to Vegas, I could combine it with a bunch of other destinations that I really love, like Zion National Park in southern Utah and… well… Vegas. (And yes, I know that exhibitors are concerned that their potential convention customers would be waylaid by shiny, jingly slot machines and the like and not spend anything on comics. That’s a perfectly reasonable concern, but as usual, I’m coming at this from an entirely selfish perspective.)

Update: Speaking of cons, there’s a terrific roundtable on girls and fandom up at Robot 6.

Elsewhere at The Comics Reporter, Tom points to this article about someone snatching up domain names of people, including an emerging queer performer, to post virulently anti-gay evangelical comics. (I know they aren’t just anti-gay, but that’s what initially got my hackles up.) Nothing communicates a heartfelt desire to share one’s faith like ambushing people expecting something completely different while robbing an artist of a potential venue to promote his or her work.

License Request Day: Prix Asie

Earlier this week, The Comics Reporter noted this year’s Prix Asie award winner and runners-up. The Prix Asie is presented each year by Association des Critiques et journalistes de Bande Dessinee (ACBD) to a worthy Asian comic that’s been published in French. So for this week’s License Request Day, I thought I’d run down the contenders and reinforce of our envy of the comic-reading French. Again, I’ve probably taken some serious liberties with the translation of the publishers’ solicitation text, so feel free to correct me if you spot something soul-crushingly egregious or just garden-variety wrong.

undercurrentThe prize went to Undercurrent, which is the title that I’m most interested in seeing published in English. It was written and illustrated by Tetsuya Toyoda and published in French by Kana and originally serialized in Kodansha’s Afternoon magazine:

“Kanae manages a public bathhouse with her husband, Satoru. Both are helped in their task by Kanae’s aunt. When Satoru disappears mysteriously, the rumours swirl: accident, escape, secret liaison… Many judge Kanae to be too authoritative, too independent. Unable to manage the business without her husband, Kanae takes in a young man, Hori, sent by the trade union of the public baths to help her. Presented in a manga with clear graphics is the story of a meeting place and separations where tragedy crosses comedy, where feelings of gratitude mix with major regrets.”

The other nominees were:

enfantsoldatEnfant Soldat by Akira Fuyaka and Aki Ra, published in French by Delcourt, originally serialized in Shueisha’s Business Jump magazine:

“A ten-year-old boy, whose mother was killed by the Khmer Rouges, must take up weapons to survive the massacres. He lives then in total unconsciousness of his actions, ignorant that of other ways of life than that of the soldiers. Shifting between the forces of Pol Pot, those of Vietnam and Kampuchea, it delivers testimony to us; a drama that humanity should not forget.”

gringoGringo by Osamu Tezuka, published in French by Kana, originally serialized in Shogakukan’s Big Comic magazine:

“In 1982, in a world where competition is fierce, a large Japanese company names Hitoshi Himoto, 35, to a high position in its South American subsidiary company. Hitoshi has to give up his dream of being a sumo wrestler, but he’s conscious of this exceptional promotion and determined to make his way! The difficulty is that these duties are in a zone controlled by guerrillas directed by the terrible Jose Garcia. Hitoshi lands in the banana republic of Santa Luna. He discovers another world there: dictatorship, misery, corruption, insurrection. By chance, Hitoshi discovers the existence of rare metals for electronics. From now on regarded as the “gringo,” Hitoshi will have to face multiple obstacles to negotiate with the rebels for access, the purchase and export of the invaluable ores while navigating the local politics and their hierarchy! Gringo immerses us in political-financial intrigue always with the inimitable style of the Master of manga.”

intermezzoIntermezzo by Tori Miki, published in French by IMHO, originally published by Kawade:

“An explosive mix of Monthy Python and the absurd humour of Gary Larson, Intermezzo looks at the chaotic and surrealist life of a bookseller who spends his days lost in parallel universes. Extraterrestrial nuttiness, divergent realities, impromptu modifications of the laws of physics, this worldess comic strip plays with the conventions of the form with humour and intelligence. Intermezzo is composed of different stand-alone comic strips and is part of a cycle of four albums (each one being able to be read separately).”

Update: In the comments, José Filipe notes that an English-language version of Intermezzo, titled Anywhere But Here, has already been published by Fantagraphics. And, I suppose I should have noticed that translations probably don’t matter that much with a wordless comic, do they? Here’s their solicitation text for the book:

“The American debut of one of Japan’s most distinctive humorous voices. Tori Miki has won awards for his essays, screenplays and manga, including the prestigious Bunshun Manga Award. With four best-selling volumes released to date, the comic strip series Anywhere But Here is one of his greatest successes. Running weekly in Japan’s TV Bros, a respected magazine of television and media criticism, Anywhere But Here is a wordless comic strip that could perhaps best be described as ‘Monty Python meets The Far Side meets Zen humor.’ Miki’s unnamed lead character (modelled after himself) works as a bookstore owner but somehow finds himself entangled with aliens, alternate realities, and other mysterious disturbances in the space-time continuum. Like Gary Larson’s The Far Side, Anywhere But Here can leave you scratching your head in bemusement almost as often as it makes you laugh, but we’ve selected the very best of his first two volumes for this special collection, printed in an elegant two-color edition.”

JQ_UneVieChinoise.qxdUne vie chinoise by P. Ôtié and Li Kunwu, published in French by Kana:

“A completely new manga told from the inside by a Chinese author who lived through the vertiginous rise of the Communism of Mao Zedong. This autobiography makes us share the insane destiny of the Chinese given birth to by Mao Zedong in the 1950s, to today’s revolutions in counter-revolutions under the reins of modern China. It is an enthralling voyage in time, mixing nostalgia and awakening, accurately respecting the historical facts and references with an almost clinical approach to the subject.”

Prism offers Queer Press Grant

Hey, LGBT comics creators: Prism Comics wants to give you money so you can… y’know… keep making comics. The full press release is below, which includes details on Prism’s planned portfolio review at Comic-Con International. (Honestly, I’d scribble something horrible on hotel stationary just to meet the reviewers.)

prism_logo

San Diego, CA — Prism Comics is seeking submissions for its fifth annual Queer Press Grant, established to support and encourage new LGBT comics creators. In conjunction, Prism will again offer portfolio review at this year’s San Diego Comic-Con International exclusively for those interested in applying to the grant.

“We were very happy to offer portfolio review last year,” says David Stanley, Prism Co-President. “It was terrifically helpful for the applicants and the reviewers enjoyed it tremendously, as well.

The application deadline for the Prism Comics Queer Press Grant is October 1, 2009. Application guidelines are detailed on the Prism Comics website at prismcomics.org/grant. Completed applications, along with queries about the grant, can be submitted by email to grants at prismcomics dot org.

Past winners of the grant include Steve MacIsaac (Shiftlifter), Megan Gedris (YU+ME), Tommy Roddy (Pride High), Justin Hall (Glamazonia), and Pam Harrison (House of the Muses). The grant award began with $1,000 for the first recipient and the amount has increased over the years depending on fundraising; last year’s award was $2,000.

Portfolio review will be offered at the 2009 San Diego Comic-Con International exclusively to those interested in applying for the Queer Press Grant. Among the industry professionals offering advice and critique will be Phil Jimenez (The Amazing Spider-Man, Infinite Crisis), Bob Schreck (Editor, who has worked at DC Comics and Vertigo) and Colleen Coover (X-Men: First Family Class, Small Favors). Before attending the sessions, applicants are required to read through the application guidelines, available at prismcomics.org/grant.

Manga Eisner straw poll

Just out of curiosity, I thought I’d test the waters and see what you all thought about the race for this year’s Eisner Award for Best U.S. Edition of International Material – Japan. Comics professionals can cast their official vote through June 15, but I’m nosy and impatient. I’ll check back in on June 16 to see which title “won.”

You may notice that I didn’t put in an “Other” option, not that I don’t want to hear what titles you think were neglected (as I’ve contributed to such discussions myself), but because people viewing the poll results can’t see voters’ write-in nominations. So hopefully you’ll cast your vote in the actual ballot and, if you aren’t satisfied with the choices, post a comment naming the book you’d vote for in a perfect world.

I’ll post my pick after the jump. It’s like how you can’t have campaign signs within a certain distance of a polling place.

Dororo1From the official selections, I’m going to let sentiment win the day and cast my vote for Osamu Tezuka’s Dororo (Vertical). I’ll just repeat what I said over at The Comics Reporter:

“Between the premise and the moody undertones, it feels like I could have read dozens of volumes of Dororo without becoming bored. That I won’t get the chance probably plays a significant part in the book being so fixed in my thinking. The rushed conclusion has a melancholy beyond its basic narrative elements, which isn’t unusual for Tezuka, but the speculation on what could have followed and how the story could have unfurled give that melancholy an extra layer.”

Diary_coverF.inddIt’s a tough call, and I still might have voted for Dororo even if my alternate had been nominated, but I would have loved the chance to decide between it and Hideo Azuma’s Disappearance Diary (Fanfare/Ponent Mon). Again, I’ll be lazy and quote myself:

“For as much of a prig as I can be about the behavior and morality of fictional characters, I found myself unexpectedly complicit with the Azuma portrayed in Disappearance Diary. I certainly can’t support the choices that yielded these experiences, but I got quite a bit of reading pleasure out of watching Azuma chronicle them. Perhaps he viewed his failures as such a given that it would have been redundant to dwell on them. Perhaps he really isn’t contrite in the least.”

Precincts reporting

Division by genre is maintaining a fairly consistent lead over division by demographic category in yesterday’s poll. Genre proponents entirely outnumber demographic supporters in the comments, so I’d love to hear from people who like the idea of awards under the shônen-shôjo-seinen-josei-etc. umbrella.

Wednesday poll

Over at Comics Worth Reading, Ed Sizemore takes a look at the The Society for the Promotion of Japanese Animation Industry Awards Ballot and makes some interesting, genre-centered suggestions on what a manga awards could look like. Over at About.Com, Deb Aoki rounds up a nice list of titles that could have fit in nicely in a number of Eisner Award categories.

Since the notion has been in the back of my mind lately, I thought I would throw out a quick poll on one structural aspect of a possible manga awards program.