The Manga Curmudgeon

Spending too much on comics, then talking too much about them

  • Home
  • About
  • One Piece MMF
  • Sexy Voice & Robo MMF
  • Comics links
  • Year 24 Group links

From the stack: Ikigami vol. 2

September 8, 2009 by David Welsh

Ikigami: The Ultimate Limit (Viz) is about a governmental experiment in social engineering where random young people are killed to encourage the remainder of the citizenry a greater appreciation for life. The condemned are given 24 hours notice by the bureaucracy. You’d think the most engrossing material would come from how they spend their last day. In the second volume, as with the first, I was much more intrigued by the framing-device functionary who delivers the bad news and tries to make sure the people he notifies don’t do anything drastic.

This time around, our young bearer of bad news is finding that the grind of the job, the minute-to-minute demands and stresses, is blurring his underlying moral concerns. He’s becoming callous to his charges, a soulless paper pusher.

ikigami2scan

Scenes like the one above are chilling and very effective. They constitute a small fraction of the book as a whole, but they’re far and away the best reasons to read the book. These scant pages of context say more about a repugnant initiative than the portrayals of its victims.

That isn’t to say that those portrayals are bad, exactly. Creator Motoro Mase certainly has a penchant for melodrama and a reasonable enough aptitude for portraying it, but there’s a bluntness to these sequences that’s much less interesting than the sly, layered glimpses of the system’s operational details.

This time around, we get two contrasting stories. The first strains to teach a valuable lesson about drug abuse in a thoroughly by-the-numbers fashion. In my opinion, Nancy Reagan left addiction narratives dead on the side of the road before I could even drive a car, and Mase isn’t storyteller enough to resuscitate them. Is anybody?

The second is potentially more interesting, as Mase is daring enough to show the end of a life with real potential. In the abstract, it highlights the dreadful arbitrariness of the program and how harmful it can be to society, or at least a corner of it. Moment to moment, Mase is more concerned with the sentiment of the experience, which mutes the story’s potential to condemn.

But I keep coming back to those creepy, bureaucratic moments and the deft handling of tone and undercurrent they display. For now, they’re enough to carry me through the only average majority of the comic for the spikes of sneaky, economical subplot.

Filed Under: From the stack, Viz

Working for a living

September 7, 2009 by David Welsh

analAmong my various comics partialities, I really like stories that rely heavily on specific workplaces or careers. From advertising agencies to cafés to bakeries to afterlife bureaucracies to manor houses to airlines to quasi-legal think tanks to voice-over studios off-the-books medical clinics, I find it hard to resist comics characters who are on the job. Since there are so many comics about them, I tend not to count teachers or officers of law enforcement in this category; they virtually have categories of their own.

So in honor of Labor Day and in hopes of finding more careerist manga, here are some jobs that I feel are underrepresented in comics:

fakeRealtors: Thanks to HGTV, there aren’t many untold aspects of the real-estate profession, so I’m thinking of a weirder take on the topic. It occurs to me that fictional vampires and demons and sorcerers always have great old money pits in which to reside, but how do they acquire them? It then occurs to me that there must be specialists in finding just the right dilapidated pile of stone for just the right supernatural or other-dimensional buyers. They might even have interior designers on staff to make sure the cobwebs are just so and the wallpaper is suitably stained and peeling. And they certainly track the crime reports to find properties with the kind of history that might make them unattractive to the average mortal. (Stubborn bloodstains lower resale value!)

Park Rangers: I just love national parks. They’re beautiful and varied settings, and all kinds of things happen there, from sentimental moments to dangerous moments to teachable moments. Take your pick.

shoutoutloudTravel writers: This is basically the urban version of the previous entry, but with a focus on cityscapes rather than canyons or forests. If I were forced to pick, I’d probably go with a murder mystery angle since the setting would change frequently. Then you could avoid the whole question of why everyone didn’t move away from Cabot Cove since it had such an astonishingly high homicide rate for a small town in Maine.

Wedding planners: This actually triggered this train of thought. I went to a wedding over the weekend, and I have to say that I always find them weird, whether high-end or on the cheap. The subject seems like an endless source of episodic story fodder, what with all the bridezillas and groomalons, and the flowers, gowns, food and décor seem like a veritable buffet of illustrative possibilities. In my dream version, it’s a smutty, subversive take on the subject with a decided yaoi bent, starring gay wedding planners to agitate for marriage equality in their spare time. As for the smut, few settings inspire ill-advised trysting like celebrations of undying fidelity.

That should do for a start. I promise not to sue if you decide to make a comic about any of the above.

Filed Under: Wishful thinking

Despair is in the details

September 6, 2009 by David Welsh

glossary

Would I use a three-day weekend as an excuse to slack off on a new Flipped column? Well, of course I would, but I didn’t in this instance. In fact, it’s even a day early. If Joyce Aurino can do all of that homework translating and adapting Koji Kumeta’s Sayonara, Zetsubou-Sensei (Del Rey), then the least I can do is say nice things about her work.

nice

Filed Under: Del Rey, Flipped

Birthday book: Leave It to Chance

September 4, 2009 by David Welsh

Today’s Birthday Book fills me with nostalgia, not just for the book itself but for the work of Paul Smith in general. His run on Uncanny X-Men (collected here) remains one of my favorites in super-hero comics, packed with watershed moments made even better by his terrific pencils. In fact, I’d go so far as to say it was the title’s last great huzzah.

leaveittochanceBut today’s title is actually an independent work Smith did with James Robinson for Image: Leave it to Chance. It ran for a mere thirteen issues, but it was really terrific while it lasted. I like the Publishers Weekly description on the book’s Amazon listing so much that I’ll just crib from it:

“Like the Nancy Drew mysteries that inspired it, Robinson’s newest work is a paean to the resourcefulness and spirit of a curious tomboyish type who’s addicted to adventure. Chance Falconer is a 14-year-old only child born into a family of municipal sorcerers that has protected the city of Devil’s Echo for centuries. Chance can’t wait to start training in the family business, but her father decides he doesn’t want a girl joining the family’s dangerous profession… This is a girl power comic written with a younger audience in mind. The smartest cops are female, the violence is G-rated and the story is fast-paced, brightly colored and as wholesome as it gets.”

I’d be reluctant to use the word “wholesome,” just because nobody could possibly take that as a compliment, but the rest is spot-on. I’m horrified by my suspicion that it’s out of print, because I would have pegged this as an absolute perennial. Surely someone should have an omnibus edition in the offing, shouldn’t they?

Filed Under: Birthday books, Image, Marvel

License request day: Chi's Sweet Home

September 4, 2009 by David Welsh

startled

chi1So apparently someone has decided that the internet needs “A Day Without Cats” next Tuesday. It’s some kind of National Day of Silence where everyone agrees not to tell cute cat stories or post cute cat pictures or video, and I’m not really clear why it’s necessary. I mean, there are lots of other things I’d like to see the internet go a day without, you know?

But far be it from me to be purposely contrarian. On Tuesday, Sept. 9, I will continue my fairly impressive track record of not telling cute cat stories or posting cute cat pictures. Well, it was a fairly impressive track record until today, when I beg some publisher to bring English-reading audiences what appears to be the cutest cat manga ever.

pleasedOf course I’m talking about Chi’s Sweet Home, written and illustrated Konami Kanata and serialized in Kodansha’s Weekly Morning magazine. Here’s the sometimes-reliable Wikipedia’s description of the series:

“A gray and white kitten with black stripes wanders away from her mother and siblings one day while enjoying a walk outside with her family. Lost in her surroundings, the kitten struggles to find her family and instead is found by a young boy, Youhei, and his mother. They take the kitten home, but as pets are not allowed in their housing complex, they try to find her a new home. chi2This proves to be difficult, and the family decides to keep the kitten. While being housebroken, she mistakenly answers to ‘Chi,’ (the Japanese word for ‘small’, can also be ‘pee’) and this becomes her name. Chi then has a splendid time living with her new family, learning about different things and meeting new people and animals.”

careerOkay, so it sounds like it’s Yotsuba with a kitten instead of a green-haired pre-schooler. I don’t see a down side to this, but I’m a cat person. (Before anyone gets their hackles up, I’m also a dog person. There appear to be six collected volumes available, which is not at all unreasonable, though it’s ongoing, so who knows how many there’ll eventually be? I don’t really care, because CUTE KITTENS DOING CUTE THINGS.

chi5Morning is in the seinen category, but I’ve always gotten the impression that it’s more for people who like great comics than 20-something men who like fanservice and weaponry, though I’m sure it’s perfectly capable of delivering those qualities with brio. Morning has been home to manga by Fumi Yoshinaga, Moyoco Anno, and Fuyumi Soryo, along with Planetes and Vagabond, so it seems as though the manga must only be made of freshly minted win to have a place in the roster.

Chi’s Sweet Home seems to have that feline je ne sais quoi that could fill a niche in the existing market. Sure, predicting what Kodansha will do has proven to be impossible, but when it comes down to cute kitten manga, the request must be made. And when Tuesday comes and you’re feeling that withdrawal, know that at least a few cute kitten pictures are here for you.

Update: Commenter Althalus notes that Ediciones Glénat will be is publishing the book in Spanish.

romping

Filed Under: License requests

Audience development: Real

September 3, 2009 by David Welsh

Welcome to another new, hopefully semi-regular feature where I hope to highlight some really good comics that you probably aren’t reading. Let’s start with Takehiko Inoue’s Real (Viz). As I see it, there are two main reasons Real might not have found the audience it deserves.

real1The first may be the fact that Real is perceived as sports manga, which seems to be right up there with josei in terms of stateside salability. Sports manga partisans are devoted, but they are not numerous. Now, I have a theory as to why this category might be significantly less popular in the United States than it is in Japan. It involves a fair amount of stereotyping, so I apologize in advance if this reasoning doesn’t apply to you, and I acknowledge that there will certainly be exceptions, possibly numerous.

Now, we all know that a much larger percentage of Japanese kids read comics than kids in the United States do. It’s a much more normalized activity for kids there. And, in my experience, comics are one of the things American kids enjoy instead of sports. With a much larger population of comics-reading kids in Japan, it seems much more likely that a healthy percentage of them enjoy comics in addition to sports and consequently enjoy seeing one of their hobbies dramatized in that format. Speaking only for myself, I already feel like competitive athletics are sufficiently glamorized in more than enough venues, so I would much prefer if they kept their muddy cleat prints off of my comics, thank you very much.

real3But Real isn’t actually a sports manga. It’s a character-driven drama. There’s certainly athletic activity being portrayed, and some characters are motivated by their desire to excel in competitive sports, but that’s really just one color in the book’s spectrum of aspirations. It’s much more about achieving independence and respect, which are much more universal.

This brings me to the second possible hurdle to wanting to read Real: the fact that most of its protagonists are coping with a disability. Works that dramatize the experience of overcoming a disability struggle with some unfortunate (and often accurate) preconceptions: that they are mawkish in their attempts to uplift or self-righteous in their attempts to educate.

real5Real suffers from neither of those failings. It’s gritty and funny and, as I noted before, driven by complex characters. There are no plaster saints in Inoue’s cast. That’s not to say that they’re unsympathetic, and I think the fact that they can be obnoxious or alienating makes the audience’s sympathetic reaction more genuine. Their flaws negate the potentially queasy feeling of abstract pity in favor of actual identification.

Real is also magnificently drawn, as I’ve noted previously. That never hurts, especially when an artist folds as much emotion and subtext into his or her illustrations as Inoue does here. So, honestly, if you’re avoiding Real because it’s about sports or because you fear movie-of-the-week moralizing about the resilient disabled, I can assure you that you’ve nothing to fear. It’s a great comic with engrossing characters, and it deserves a larger readership. Five volumes are currently available in English, so you aren’t even really that far behind, as these things go.

(Got a book you feel deserves some audience development? Like to write a guest column about it? E-mail me and we’ll see what we can do.)

Filed Under: Audience development, Viz

From the stack: Astral Project 4

September 2, 2009 by David Welsh

ap4I don’t usually feel compelled to write a proper review of every volume of a given manga series. There are too many of them, to be honest, and I’m usually too lazy. I have to make an exception for Astral Project (CMX), written by marginal (Garon Tsuchiya, an Eisner winner for Old Boy) and illustrated by Syuji Takeya. For one thing, the series is only four volumes long, which is well within even my parameters for sloth. For another, it’s amazing and constantly surprising, right up to the finish.

To summarize, a young man’s sister commits suicide. He finds a CD of little-known jazz music among her belongings and takes it as a keepsake. When he plays it, his spirit leaves his body. When he leaves his body, he meets a motley crew of other astral travelers, finding companionship, suspicion, and the possibility of romance. As Masahiko tries to understand the circumstances of his sister’s death, he finds that Asami’s suicide was just a small part of a much larger mystery.

After reading the third volume, I had no idea how Tsuchiya was going to wrap things up with so many narrative elements in play – mysteries, conspiracies, secrets, complex relationships, and so on. He manages it with an unexpected display of economy. Everything that really needs to be explained is explained, though it never feels like it’s being explained, if that makes any sense.

So many plot threads in play could come cross as frantic, and that’s not always bad. I often find Naoki Urasawa’s 20th Century Boys (Viz) a little on the frantic side, and that’s one of the things I really like about the series. But Astral Project takes its cues from its spiritually adrift protagonists, floating from one thread to another, seeing what there is to be seen. (I should note that I don’t think Takeya is nearly as good an illustrator as Urasawa is, but the pages are never less than competent, and Takeya can hit some nice highs along the way.)

The potential for hubbub is also mitigated by the philosophizing, which ends up being refreshingly character-driven. The underlying theories that inform the work as articulated in this last volume are a little chilling, more than a little scathing, and unexpectedly hilarious. It’s all about real versus virtual life. Having witnessed one online platform clogged to dysfunction by people responding to a short-term failure of another online platform just yesterday, Tsuchiya’s conspiracy theories also seem unnervingly plausible.

But whether you agree with Tsuchiya or not, Astral Project is just a joy to read. It’s smart, rangy in its interests, funny, suspenseful, and even a little sweet when circumstances demand it be so. If your resistance to manga is rooted in its sometimes juvenile concerns and the daunting length of some highly regarded series, then I can’t recommend this book strongly enough.

Filed Under: CMX, From the stack

Upcoming 9/2/2009

September 1, 2009 by David Welsh

Time for a quick look at this week’s ComicList:

stitchesIn a given year, you usually get one original graphic novel as ambitious and accomplished as David Mazzucchelli’s Asterios Polyp (Pantheon). That splendid book will have to make room for David Small’s Stitches (W.W. North), due to arrive Wednesday. It’s an extraordinary autobiographical graphic novel about the horrors of Small’s childhood, but it’s completely without self-indulgence or meandering. Small’s ability to compose his experiences into a complex, disturbing narrative is absolutely miraculous. It’s a true story that flows and breathes like the best made-up story, and I think everyone should read it. I really, really do.

I was quite taken with Natsuna Kawase’s The Lapis Lazuli Crown (CMX), though I found myself a little less impressed with Kawase’s earlier work, A Tale of an Unknown Country (also CMX and due this week). It’s not without its charms, but it’s easy to see how much Kawase refined her storytelling skills between the two works. I agree with Johanna Draper Carlson’s review of Country.

sandchron6This is one of those weeks when Viz decides to release loads and loads of manga upon an unsuspecting public, including many of their very best shôjo titles. Those include:

  • the 11th volume of Kazune Kawahara’s High School Debut
  • the 7th volume of Chica Umino’s Honey and Clover
  • the 18th volume of Ai Yazawa’s NANA
  • and the 6th volume of Hinako Ashihara’s Sand Chronicles.
  • If the total at the cash register doesn’t already have you crying, not to worry. The comics themselves probably will.

    Filed Under: CMX, ComicList, Linkblogging, Viz, W.W. Norton

    Twists and turns

    August 31, 2009 by David Welsh

    First, there’s a new Flipped up over at The Comics Reporter. I worked really hard on it, and even I don’t even care any more, because, wow, what’s the opposite of a slow news day? Monday, Aug. 31, 2009, that’s what the opposite is.

    Since Marvel and Disney are so 10:18 a.m., I’ll point you towards Brigid Alverson’s scoop that Kodansha is letting its licenses with Tokyopop lapse. I popped over to Wikipedia to see if there was any handy chart or graph that would allow me to compare original publisher and U.S. licensing agent, and voila. It’s incomplete and should probably be taken with whatever quantity of salt you usually apply to that particular resource, but it’s a start, and here are the titles I culled (with an updated pointer to Deb Aoki’s breakdown of which titles are unfinished):

    A.I. Love You
    Baby Birth
    Beck: Mongolian Chop Squad
    Blame!
    Boys Be…
    Cardcaptor Sakura
    (due for omnibus treatment from Dark Horse, I think)
    Cherry Juice
    Chobits
    (due for omnibus treatment from Dark Horse)
    Clover
    (available in new omnibus from Dark Horse)
    Confidential Confessions
    Culdcept
    Cyborg 009
    Dead End
    Deus Vitae
    Dragon Head
    Dragon Voice
    Dream Saga
    Et Cetera
    FLCL
    Flower of Eden
    (licensed but never published)
    GetBackers
    Girl Got Game
    Great Teacher Onizuka
    GTO: The Early Years
    Harlem BeatRebound
    Heat Guy J
    Ice Blade
    Initial D
    Instant Teen: Just Add Nuts
    Jing: King of Bandits
    Kami Kaze
    Kamichama Karin
    Kedamono Damono
    Kilala Princess
    Kindaichi Case Files
    Life
    Love Hina
    Magic Knight Rayearth
    Magical Shopping Arcade Abenobashi
    Mars
    Mink
    Miracle Girls
    Mobile Fighter G Gundam
    Mobile Suit Gundam Side Story: The Blue Destiny
    Mobile Suit Gundam Wing
    Parasyte
    (since published anew by Del Rey)
    Peach Girl
    and spin-offs
    Pixie Pop
    Planetes
    Le Portrait de Petite Cossette
    Psychic Academy
    Rave Master
    Remote
    RG Veda
    Rose Hip Rose
    Sailor Moon
    Saint Tail
    Sakura Taisen
    Samurai Deeper Kyo
    (picked up by Del Rey)
    Smuggler
    Telepathic Wanderers
    Tokyo Mew Mew
    and sequel
    Tramps Like Us
    Voices of a Distant Star
    Warriors of Tao
    Zodiac P.I.

    Feel free to note any I missed in the comments, and I’ll update the list.

    Filed Under: Flipped, Linkblogging, Tokyopop

    Previews review Sept. 2009

    August 31, 2009 by David Welsh

    There’s a fair amount of interesting new stuff in the September 2009 edition of Diamond’s Previews catalog, along with a positively crippling number of new volumes of ongoing series that I simply must have. Let’s go in page order, shall we?

    chobitsDark Horse continues its CLAMP collection project with the Chobits Omnibus Edition, a 720-page trade paperback priced at $24.95 (page 44).

    It’s always unnerving when I read a quote from myself in something like this or on a book cover, because I sound even dorkier excerpted than I do in context, but I’m always happy to sing the praises of The Kurosagi Corpse Delivery Service, written by Eiji Otsuka and illustrated by Jousui Yamazaki (page 50). The tenth volume solicitation seems to hint at the participation of zombies, but you should all buy it anyway. It’s not like it’s vampires.

    CMX should have put some kind of sad-face emoticon after “Final Volume!” in their solicitation for the tenth volume of Kaoru Mori’s Emma. It’s back to focusing on the leads for the big finish (page 123).

    I really liked the first volume of Nina Matsumoto’s Yokaiden (Del Rey), so I’m glad to see the listing for the second installment (page 248).

    Digital Manga Publishing busts out the old-school shôjo with the first volume of Kaoru Tada’s Itazura Na Kiss (page 251). As the heroine seems to be something of an academic underachiever, I’d put good money on there being a scene where she’s late for school and runs out the door with a piece of toast hanging out of her mouth. That is not a criticism.

    yellowI’ve been meaning to read Makoto Tateno’s Yellow for ages, as it sometimes shows up on those lists of yaoi titles gay guys might like. DMP offers the first volume of an omnibus version of the series, just in time for the arrival of the first volume of Yellow 2 (page 253).

    If I didn’t already own all of the single issues, I would probably buy The More Than Complete Action Philosophers trade paperback from Evil Twin, written by Fred Van Lente and illustrated by Ryan Dunlavey. Actually, I’ll probably buy it anyway, because those comics are great, and I’d love to have them all bundled up (page 257).

    yourandmysecret5Oh, glorious day! Tokyopop finally releases the fifth volume of Ai Morinaga’s pointed and hilarious Your and My Secret. The body-switching, pansexual love quadrangle continues (page 292).

    Vertical gets in on the act with the eighth volume of Osamu Tezuka’s addictive Black Jack (page 300). I want a “Pinoko’s Most Unnerving Moments” edition. Though honestly, that would be all of them.

    childrenofthesea2Viz has been inching me towards financial ruin for ages now, but they really give it their best effort this time around. There are the second volumes of Fumi Yoshinaga’s Ôoku: The Inner Chambers and Daisuke Igarashi’s Children of the Sea, the third volume of Kiminori Wakasugi’s Detroit Metal City, and the sixth volume of Naoki Urasawa’s 20th Century Boys, all on page 305.

    Last, but certainly not least, Yen Press delivers the second volume of Yuji Iwahara’s Cat Paradise (page 310). For those of you who skipped the first installment, it’s about a school that lets you bring your cat. Charming as that sounds, many of the cats and their owners pursue extracurricular activities that involve fighting big, horrible demons. Fun stuff.

    Filed Under: CMX, Dark Horse, Del Rey, DMP, Evil Twin, Tokyopop, Vertical, Viz, Yen Press

    « Previous Page
    Next Page »

    Features

    • Fruits Basket MMF
    • Josei A to Z
    • License Requests
    • Seinen A to Z
    • Shôjo-Sunjeong A to Z
    • The Favorites Alphabet

    Categories

    Recent Posts

    • Hiatus
    • Upcoming 11/30/2011
    • Upcoming 11/23/2011
    • Undiscovered Ono
    • Re-flipped: not simple

    Comics

    • 4thletter!
    • Comics Alliance
    • Comics Should Be Good
    • Comics Worth Reading
    • Comics-and-More
    • Comics212
    • comiXology
    • Fantastic Fangirls
    • Good Comics for Kids
    • I Love Rob Liefeld
    • Mighty God King
    • Neilalien
    • Panel Patter
    • Paul Gravett
    • Polite Dissent
    • Progressive Ruin
    • Read About Comics
    • Robot 6
    • The Comics Curmudgeon
    • The Comics Journal
    • The Comics Reporter
    • The Hub
    • The Secret of Wednesday's Haul
    • Warren Peace
    • Yet Another Comics Blog

    Manga

    • A Case Suitable for Treatment
    • A Feminist Otaku
    • A Life in Panels
    • ABCBTom
    • About.Com on Manga
    • All About Manga
    • Comics Village
    • Experiments in Manga
    • Feh Yes Vintage Manga
    • Joy Kim
    • Kuriousity
    • Manga Out Loud
    • Manga Report
    • Manga Therapy
    • Manga Views
    • Manga Widget
    • Manga Worth Reading
    • Manga Xanadu
    • MangaBlog
    • Mecha Mecha Media
    • Ogiue Maniax
    • Okazu
    • Read All Manga
    • Reverse Thieves
    • Rocket Bomber
    • Same Hat!
    • Slightly Biased Manga
    • Soliloquy in Blue
    • The Manga Critic

    Pop Culture

    • ArtsBeat
    • Monkey See
    • Postmodern Barney
    • Something Old, Nothing New

    Publishers

    • AdHouse Books
    • Dark Horse Comics
    • Del Rey
    • Digital Manga
    • Drawn and Quarterly
    • Fanfare/Ponent Mon
    • Fantagraphics Books
    • First Second
    • Kodansha Comics USA
    • Last Gasp
    • NBM
    • Netcomics
    • Oni Press
    • SLG
    • Tokyopop
    • Top Shelf Productions
    • Vertical
    • Viz Media
    • Yen Press

    Archives

    Copyright © 2026 · Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in