The Manga Curmudgeon

Spending too much on comics, then talking too much about them

  • Home
  • About
  • One Piece MMF
  • Sexy Voice & Robo MMF
  • Comics links
  • Year 24 Group links

License request day: Love My Life

June 18, 2010 by David Welsh

During yesterday’s discussion of manga Rachel Maddow might like, Dirk Deppey pushed the boundaries by suggesting manga that Rachel Maddow might like were it to be published in English. (For all I know, Maddow might read Japanese or French fluently in addition to her other super-powers.) He pointed me in the direction of Ebine Yamaji, and while I resisted the siren call of scanlations, her comics do sound pretty great.

I would particularly love it if some kind soul were to pick up Love My Life. To be honest, if I was in the lead character’s situation, I’d love my life too. (Not that I don’t, but you know what I mean.)

“Ichiko Izumiya is an eighteen-year-old woman who goes to language school in university and works part-time at a music store. She lives with her father, Housei Izumiya, and he translates English novels into Japanese for a living. Her mother died seven years before the story begins. Ichiko also has a girlfriend named Eri Joujima. When she comes out as a lesbian to her father, her father shocks her by telling her that both he and her mother are also gay. They had wanted to raise a child, and had agreed to marry in name to raise a child in Japan, while mutually being in their own relationships. The rest of the story shows Ichiko meeting her parents’ lovers, her everyday life and love with Eri, in a slice of life, upbeat and positive style.”

Okay, just… Sold. Want.

It’s one volume long and originally ran in Shodensha’s Feel Young magazine, which has published josei by some really fabulous creators. It’s been published in French by Asuka. You can also look at some preview pages (in Japanese).

Filed Under: License requests

Manga for Maddow

June 17, 2010 by David Welsh

I really admire Rachel Maddow and think she’s brilliant, and I’m thrilled to learn that she loves comic books and graphic novels. But her list of favorites? The usual suspects.

So this has me wondering what manga I’d recommend she read. She seems to like stories with political underpinnings (no surprise there), so here are some starting points:

  • 20th Century Boys, written and illustrated by Naoki Urasawa. You could basically recommend anything by Urasawa, but I like this series best.
  • Real, written and illustrated by Takehiko Inoue. It’s not especially political, but it’s really good, and I just like recommending it to people, especially if there’s a chance they might mention it in a YouTube video.
  • Ooku: The Inner Chambers, written and illustrated by Fumi Yoshinaga. It doesn’t get more political than this, really, Fakespeare aside.
  • Tekkonkinkreet, written and illustrated by Taiyo Matsumoto. GoGo Monster is actually better, but I think this title’s urban underpinnings might appeal to Maddow.
  • Thoughts?

    Filed Under: Awards and lists

    All things eventually considered

    June 16, 2010 by David Welsh

    I really enjoy reading NPR’s Monkey See blog, particularly Glen Weldon’s occasional musings on comics and graphic novels. I do find myself wishing he’d write more about manga, and while there’s a little “Be careful what you wish for…” in the mix, I think he offers a very readable overview of the current State of Things:

    “The next time I came into work, I saw that he hadn’t given the books more prominent placement or allotted them any extra shelf space. Instead, he’d simply slapped a fancy embossed shelftag under them, reading:

    “MAGNA [sic]: COMICS FOR GIRLS AND LADIES!!!!”

    For bonus points, the blog is run by Linda Holmes, who wrote for Television Without Pity back when it was really, really good.

    Filed Under: Linkblogging

    Upcoming 6/16/2010

    June 15, 2010 by David Welsh

    Time for a quick look at the current ComicList:

    Fantagraphics reminds us that they’re more than just awesome, Matt Thorn-curated manga with Megan Kelso’s Artichoke Tales. Kelso’s previous big release is an excellent collection of short stories, The Squirrel Mother, also from Fantagraphics. This is Kelso’s first long-form effort, and I’m looking forward to seeing what she does with that length of narrative.

    Viz has one of its Signature-heavy weeks with three enjoyable books:

  • The first volume of Kumiko Suekane’s I’m-not-sure-how-intentionally-hilarious tale of teen-aged clones of major historical figures, Afterschool Charisma
  • The third volume of Daisuke Igarashi’s environmental fable, Children of the Sea
  • The eighth ninth volume of Naoki Urasawa’s crazily entertaining 20th Century Boys.
  • Filed Under: ComicList, Fantagraphics, Viz

    Finale thoughts

    June 14, 2010 by David Welsh

    Even if the rest of Glee‘s final episode of the season had been entirely intolerable, and one should never rule that out as a possibility when Ryan Murphy is involved, I loved the Journey medley so much that it’s almost indecent. I’m sure Hulu is wondering who in West Virginia keeps watching that clip over and over again. I had never fully realized how much I love Journey in spite of the fact that they were basically the soundtrack to my high school years. Seriously, there weren’t many traumatic experiences that weren’t scored by “Open Arms.” If that hasn’t demolished my musical credibility completely, I would like to admit that I would totally pay to see a musical constructed on the song catalog of Air Supply.

    I might have loved “To Sir, with Love” more if Quinn had been given a few solo lines. I’m always delighted to see Kurt and Santana get some of the vocal spotlight, but this song seems very much the right style for Dianna Agron’s sweet but not especially powerful singing voice, and the sentiment tracks with Quinn’s character arc. I love Santana, don’t get me wrong, but she didn’t learn anything this year, much less right from wrong.

    The show can make that minor failing up to me next year by giving Quinn and the Cheerios a crack at Nancy Sinatra’s “These Boots Are Made for Walkin’,” which would also give Heather (Brittany) Morris some awesome solo dance opportunities. I always smile when she’s on screen, particularly when she’s dancing.

    Filed Under: Musicals, TV

    Quick Previews review

    June 4, 2010 by David Welsh

    I’m packing and getting ready for some down time (restful!), but I did want to point out something for folks who pre-order at least some of their manga through Diamond’s Previews catalog. Guess what’s in the June 2010 edition?

    Page 290 in the Fantagraphics section, in case you want to go right to it. Here’s some of the solicitation text:

    “Moto Hagio is considered the most beloved shōjo manga artist of all time. Unconstrained by genre, she has built a career exemplified by intellectual curiosity, psychological authenticity and a mature aesthetic sense akin to Osamu Tezuka as opposed to Sailor Moon. For the first time in English, Fantagraphics is proud to present a Hagio primer: a selection of short stories spanning from 1971 to 2007 by an artist at the peak of her powers.”

    Needless to say, I’m super-excited and pre-ordering it as soon as I click “publish.” Of course, I’m also not even a tiny bit surprised that the blurb is obnoxious, since this is Fantagraphics. The dig at Sailor Moon, complimenting her by comparing her work to a man’s, even if that man is Osamu Tezuka… it’s vintage, really. And it has to be one of the most coherent Fantagraphics blurbs I’ve read in ages, so points for that. They usually scan like translated Latin from a codex plot device in an archeological thriller.

    Filed Under: Fantagraphics, Previews

    Upcoming 6/3/2010

    June 2, 2010 by David Welsh

    It’s not a huge week for new comics, but there are plenty of potentially enjoyable arrivals on the ComicList.

    It’s a very good week for fans of Kathryn Immonen. She’s got a new mini-series at Marvel called Heralds, illustrated by Tonci Zonic, which features a group of super-heroines dealing with a threat posed by a not-quite-dead-yet female herald of Galactus. I liked her work on the Hellcat mini-series, and in spite of its awful covers and insulting marketing, I liked Zonic’s work on Marvel Divas, which featured a number of the same characters. I’m also looking forward to seeing Hellcat and Valkyrie fighting side by side, as they were mainstays of The Defenders back in the day. I have no idea why any of these women would attend a birthday party for Emma Frost, or why Cyclops would think they’d want to do so, but…

    Kathryn Immonen teams up with gifted illustrator Stuart Immonen for Moving Pictures (Top Shelf). The publisher describes it as “the story of the awkward and dangerous relationship between curator Ila Gardner and officer Rolf Hauptmann, as they are forced by circumstances to play out their private lives in a public power struggle. The narrative unfolds along two timelines which collide with the revelation of a terrible secret, an enigmatic decision that not many would make, and the realization that sometimes the only choice left is the refusal to choose.”

    Viz does its usual first-week flood with tons of shônen and shôjo. The two most interesting-sounding debuts are Library Wars: Love and War, story and art by Kiiro Yumi, original concept by Hiro Arikawa. It’s about militarized librarians protecting books and preventing censorship. You can find approving early reviews at Manga Worth Reading and The Manga Critic.

    On the shônen front, there’s Toriko, written and illustrated by Mitsutoshi Shimabukuro. It follows the titular “Gourmet Hunter,” who must “hunt down the ferocious ingredients that supply the world’s best restaurants.” I suppose this technically counts as food manga, so I feel obligated to read it. MangaBlog’s Brigid Alverson thinks it fulfills its aims admirably.

    Elsewhere in Viz’s listings is the final volume of Chica Umino’s lovely Honey and Clover and a bunch of new volumes of Eiichiro Oda’s excellent One Piece.

    Filed Under: ComicList, Linkblogging, Marvel, Top Shelf, Viz

    Last feast, next feast

    June 1, 2010 by David Welsh

    Thanks to Kate (The Manga Critic) Dacey for doing such a bang-up job on the Manga Moveable Feast focused on Keiko Takemiya’s To Terra… (Vertical). I participated in a roundtable discussion of the book, in case you still haven’t gotten the Mu out of your system.

    Melinda (Manga Bookshelf) Beasi will host the next Moveable Feast, which will examine the trilogy of Color of… books by Kim Dong Hwa (First Second). This is notable for being the first time we’ve selected a Korean title for consideration, and it’s also the first title chosen that I actively dislike. Good times!

    Filed Under: Linkblogging, Manga Moveable Feast

    Pod people

    May 31, 2010 by David Welsh

    I don’t know if I’ll ever actually enjoy the thought of my voice being recorded to subsequently be shared online, but I do enjoy talking about great manga with smart people. Ed Sizemore recorded a Manga Out Loud podcast about Keiko Takemiya’s To Terra… (Vertical), subject of the latest Manga Moveable Feast.

    I’m weirdly excited about the upcoming Manhwa Moveable Feast, mostly because I really did not like those Color of… books, and it will be a nice change to come at the subject from a different angle.

    Filed Under: Linkblogging, Manga Moveable Feast

    License request day: Song of the Wind and the Trees

    May 28, 2010 by David Welsh

    As the current Manga Moveable Feast nears its conclusion, I thought I would consider the unlicensed Keiko Takemiya. It’s widely known that she was likely the first person to professionally publish a boys’-love comic, and yet her available-in-English work is science-fiction shônen. There are admittedly some shônen-ai underpinnings, at least in my view, but what about some unvarnished Takemiya male-on-male romance?

    For that, I would love to see her Song of the Wind and the Trees licensed by some hardy publisher. In the current discourse on the manga industries various commercial woes, some have argued that boys’ love and yaoi seem to be relatively immune to the downturn. But this is a 17-volume series that’s over 30 years old, and it’s not clear to me that the yaoi audience is particularly interested in classic material. I’m not saying they aren’t; I’m just saying that I don’t know if they are.

    It would take a publisher that’s demonstrated a commitment to archiving classic comics, which would point at Fantagraphics. Since that publisher’s manga imprint is being helmed by shôjo manga scholar Matt Thorn, and since Thorn is a colleague of Takemiya’s in the Faculty of Manga at Kyoto Seika University, the pairing seems even more apt. Also, Song of the Wind and Trees was originally published by Shogakukan, the publisher that’s partnered with Fantagraphics to a degree. Still, 17 volumes of 30-year-old manga is a risky proposition.

    So what’s it about? Here’s a bit of what Wikipedia has to say:

    “Serge Battour is the son of a wealthy man and a Roma woman. Taking place in the late 19th century, the story is a recollection of his memories of Gilbert Cocteau at Laconblade Academy in Provene, France. The story has themes of class prejudice, racism, homophobia, homosexuality, incest, pedophilia, rape, prostitution, and drug abuse.”

    That entry also notes that Takemiya refused to allow it to be published until she was promised that it would be run uncensored. It was, and it won awards, and it’s widely considered one of the first major works of shônen-ai to be published professionally.

    Here’s a link to Shogakukan’s nine-volume release of the series. It might be more reasonable to ask someone to publish Takemiya’s much shorter In the Sunroom to help fulfill the need for a representation of her boys’-love work, but why not dream big?

    Filed Under: License requests, Manga Moveable Feast

    « Previous Page
    Next Page »

    Features

    • Fruits Basket MMF
    • Josei A to Z
    • License Requests
    • Seinen A to Z
    • Shôjo-Sunjeong A to Z
    • The Favorites Alphabet

    Categories

    Recent Posts

    • Hiatus
    • Upcoming 11/30/2011
    • Upcoming 11/23/2011
    • Undiscovered Ono
    • Re-flipped: not simple

    Comics

    • 4thletter!
    • Comics Alliance
    • Comics Should Be Good
    • Comics Worth Reading
    • Comics-and-More
    • Comics212
    • comiXology
    • Fantastic Fangirls
    • Good Comics for Kids
    • I Love Rob Liefeld
    • Mighty God King
    • Neilalien
    • Panel Patter
    • Paul Gravett
    • Polite Dissent
    • Progressive Ruin
    • Read About Comics
    • Robot 6
    • The Comics Curmudgeon
    • The Comics Journal
    • The Comics Reporter
    • The Hub
    • The Secret of Wednesday's Haul
    • Warren Peace
    • Yet Another Comics Blog

    Manga

    • A Case Suitable for Treatment
    • A Feminist Otaku
    • A Life in Panels
    • ABCBTom
    • About.Com on Manga
    • All About Manga
    • Comics Village
    • Experiments in Manga
    • Feh Yes Vintage Manga
    • Joy Kim
    • Kuriousity
    • Manga Out Loud
    • Manga Report
    • Manga Therapy
    • Manga Views
    • Manga Widget
    • Manga Worth Reading
    • Manga Xanadu
    • MangaBlog
    • Mecha Mecha Media
    • Ogiue Maniax
    • Okazu
    • Read All Manga
    • Reverse Thieves
    • Rocket Bomber
    • Same Hat!
    • Slightly Biased Manga
    • Soliloquy in Blue
    • The Manga Critic

    Pop Culture

    • ArtsBeat
    • Monkey See
    • Postmodern Barney
    • Something Old, Nothing New

    Publishers

    • AdHouse Books
    • Dark Horse Comics
    • Del Rey
    • Digital Manga
    • Drawn and Quarterly
    • Fanfare/Ponent Mon
    • Fantagraphics Books
    • First Second
    • Kodansha Comics USA
    • Last Gasp
    • NBM
    • Netcomics
    • Oni Press
    • SLG
    • Tokyopop
    • Top Shelf Productions
    • Vertical
    • Viz Media
    • Yen Press

    Archives

    Copyright © 2026 · Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in