The Manga Curmudgeon

Spending too much on comics, then talking too much about them

  • Home
  • About
  • One Piece MMF
  • Sexy Voice & Robo MMF
  • Comics links
  • Year 24 Group links

It feels like it should be Wednesday already

February 21, 2006 by David Welsh

Oh, the ebb and flow of Wednesdays. It’s another hefty one, but it’s filled with all kinds of comic-y goodness.

The third issue of Andi Watson and Simon Gane’s gorgeous Paris arrives, courtesy of Slave Labor Graphics.

I’ve heard nothing but nice things about David Petersen’s Mouse Guard from Archaia Studios, and the preview images I’ve seen look really beautiful.

I’m looking forward to Put the Book Back on the Shelf: A Belle and Sebastian Anthology from Image (scroll down – quickly), even though I can’t remember ever actually listening to any of Belle and Sebastian’s music. Is that odd? (And yes, this could be construed as an invitation to make CD recommendations.)

Any week that includes a new issue of Ted Naifeh’s Polly and the Pirates (Oni) is a good week, in my opinion.

Viz’s Signature imprint begins with the arrival of the first volumes of Golgo 13 and Naoki Urasawa’s Monster.

It’s like there’s something for each of my multiple personalities.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Just another manga Monday

February 20, 2006 by David Welsh

So I got my first copy of Tokyopop’s free Manga magazine in the mail the other day. Maybe I’m tipsy over the preview chapter from the next volume of Fruits Basket, but I think it’s a very nice product. I was glad to see a preview of Dragon Head included. It’s received a number of deservedly good reviews, so I’m glad that Tokyopop is giving it an extra boost in its freebie publication. (Kami-Kaze looks kind of horrible, though.)

I think Manga might be going a little overboard on the annotations they run with their sample chapters. It’s a nice idea to give some snippets on the creative process, quotes from the creators, etc., but the text can get a little purple. It was particularly noticeable in the Sorcerers & Secretaries preview. This looks like a fun, light story, but at times the crawl read like it might have been something out of the Absolute Watchmen collection. I think they should probably lean towards breezy and informative with the running commentary. What’s there ended up actually distracting from the preview itself, which probably wasn’t the intention.

There’s a short but nice interview with Mitsuzaku Mihara that actually makes me want to take a look at Doll. Am I making a horrible mistake? I’ll have to check the lists over at MangaTrade.

In other manga news, David Taylor taunts me with an example of why television is so much better in England. (Okay, probably not all television.) He also takes a look at the latest DM manga numbers. Yay! Death Note cracked the top 100 GNs!

And lastly, it’s Monday, so it’s time for the customary self-promotion. There’s a new Flipped up where I talk about how much I like Hikaru no Go.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Swimmin' pools, TV stars

February 18, 2006 by David Welsh

The last couple of weeks of insight into Marvel’s fascinating diversity policies have left me with an unhealthy interest in the Joe Fridays column at Newsarama.

What’s on tap this week? Oddly enough, it starts off with Newsarama asking essentially the same questions about terrorists as they asked about gays last week:

“That said then, would or did Marvel ever consider a project where the threat of Al Queda is handled so directly?”

And would it have to be a MAX series?

There’s also some discussion of just why some fans might roll their eyes when Marvel makes a big deal about hiring a writer from another medium like television or film. Quesada dons protective gear for a bit of spelunking into the mind of the disgruntled fanboy:

“So, recently I’ve seen this trend of guys coming from the ocean and into our pond and suddenly fans are getting testy about it. Okay, I understand, they feel like we’re being invaded unfairly in some way or perhaps these guys somehow have not paid their dues or their debt to the comic’s society – which I’ve never understood because talent is talent. Perhaps some of these fans have aspirations to become comic writers one day and they see this as hurting their chances. Well, if that’s the case then that’s just silly and selfish.

“So, here’s all I ask folks to think about before jumping on these new talents, regardless of who they work for. Why are they doing it? Every one of these Hollywood writers – I’m using the term ‘Hollywood’ here as a general catch all for movies, TV and novels – can make infinitely more money doing something else. The week that they spend writing an issue of Wolverine is a week they can spend writing a script for TV, etc. and get paid so much more than comics. So, why, why dabble in this small pond? Could it be that these particular talents have an insatiable love for comics? I mean I could see fans being skeptical if there was more money in comics than in Hollywood, then I could at least buy into the logic that, hey, these people are only coming to comics for the money! But, that’s not the case. Guys like Whedon, Meltzer, Stracznyski, Heinberg, Lindelof, Verheiden etc. are doing it because they love comics and they love the characters and they love the universes. What more can you ask from a creator than love for this medium that we all in turn love as well. Not only that, these guys come to comics in complete awe of guys like Bendis and Johns and Millar. Now, why you would be in awe of Millar is a whole other thing, but you catch my drift. So, they’re taking a pay cut to work in a smaller field and they have complete reverence for those that came before and the characters and universe, why are we giving them a hard time?”

Oh, where, where, where to start? It’s like the platonic ideal of self-serving spin.

  1. “They’re just jealous.” I’m trying to picture the individual who might actually think, “Damnit! They hired that scriptwriter from 24! Now they’ll never buy my pitch for an Iron Man/Punisher mini! Stupid carpetbaggers!”
  2. “We should be grateful.” See, this is a bit closer to the cause of the eye-rolling, I think. Usually, it’s just an undercurrent of low self-esteem when Marvel announces a Hollywood hire. This time, it’s stripped nekkid. “These good people are sacrificing money and prestige to work with us, because they love Wolverine.” Think about that for just a minute.
  3. “Not only that, these guys come to comics in complete awe of guys like Bendis and Johns and Millar.” And isn’t that just what super-hero comics need?

Filed Under: Uncategorized

From the stack: I ♥ MARVEL: MARVEL AI

February 17, 2006 by David Welsh

C.B. Cebulski joins with three Japanese artists for three tales of super-hero romance in I ♥ Marvel: Marvel Ai (Marvel). It’s a bit of an oddity, but it’s a mostly pleasant one.

Cebulski and Tomoko Taniguchi team for “Meld with You,” a look at the Scarlet Witch’s first date with the Vision. This classic Marvel couple gets the full-tilt shôjo treatment, with borders and backgrounds swirling with flowers and stars. Cebulski provides a sensitive script that explores the couple’s early concerns and conflicts – can the android’s emotions be genuine, or are they a calculated response? Taniguichi’s adorable illustrations are a nice counterpoint to the deep feelings on display. (It is a little odd to see the Black Widow jammed into the role of Wanda’s giggly school chum, along with the Wasp, but it’s consistent with the shôjo vibe.)

There’s a decided Moto Hagio feeling to “The Silence of the Heart,” a look at the unusual challenges of marriage from the perspective of Medusa, queen of the Inhumans. Kei Kobayashi takes maximum visual advantage of Medusa’s swirling, living locks as she contemplates life with a husband, Black Bolt, who can never speak to her. It’s a lovely string of internal musings in a science fiction context.

How much you like “Love Is Blindness” will depend on how much you like jealousy-driven catfights. I don’t like them at all, so watching the Black Widow and Elektra in a rooftop throw-down over Daredevil doesn’t do much for me. Cebulski and illustrator Toga opt for pictograms instead of dialogue, which doesn’t really elevate things very much. (I keep calling the story Owly: Just a Little Bitchy in my head.)

Even with that, and the frankly bizarre anatomy on Gez Fry’s cover, there’s still a lot to like in the book. Cebulski and his collaborators have taken an unusual but often moving look at some classic Marvel couples.

Filed Under: From the stack, Marvel

From the stack: NORTHWEST PASSAGE 2

February 16, 2006 by David Welsh

The second volume of Scott Chantler’s Northwest Passage (Oni) plunges along while raising the levels of action, danger, and interpersonal conflict. It’s even better than the first, which I thought was very, very good.

Adventurer-turned-bureaucrat Charles Lord is turned out of Fort Newcastle by his vicious longtime nemesis, Guerin Montglave. As a small band of survivors races to safety, Lord searches through Rupert’s Land for reinforcements from his exploring days. Meanwhile, back at the captured fort, Montglave assumes brutal control and tries to manipulate Lord’s resentful half-Cree son, Simon.

Yes, I just used the phrase, “Meanwhile, back at the captured fort…” And you know what? I meant it. It’s that kind of book, and it’s very satisfying.

While Chantler did a fine job with a great deal of exposition in the first chapter, it’s nice to have it out of the way so he can focus more on story and character. He packs a lot of both into 88 pages, filling in detail on the histories and interpersonal dynamics of his cast while providing plenty of “Pulse-Pounding Western Action,” as the cover promises.

Chantler continues with his subtle exploration of Lord’s successes and failures as a leader. It’s a relevant thematic thread, but it isn’t an overwhelming one. Chantler never pulls out the Message Hammer, thanks in part to his willingness to acknowledge Lord’s flaws. The juxtaposition of “good” Lord and “evil” Montglave is more effective because of the things they have in common as authority figures.

At the same time, he layers the story with historical detail. Chantler informs events with observations about class, race, politics, and commerce, which make things even more satisfying. Northwest Passage is first and foremost an adventure comic, but it takes full advantage of its period and setting.

Chantler’s work as an illustrator is sterling, but that’s not surprising. His appealingly open style has proved to be wonderfully flexible, suiting a wide variety of stories and tones. Northwest Passage is no exception. There’s genuine excitement in the adventure scenes, tension to the suspense, and nuance in the character-driven moments.

What’s more surprising is that this is Chantler’s writing debut. It’s a rich, exciting story with a great balance of narrative elements.

Filed Under: From the stack, Oni

Romance, DID, and two-fisted Canadians

February 14, 2006 by David Welsh

After a couple of weeks of horrifying quantities of books showing up in my reserve file, this Wednesday seems relatively sedate. I’m not complaining, because there’s still plenty to enjoy.

I ♥ Marvel: Marvel AI features stories by C.B. Cebulski (the brains behind the developing Jetlag anthology) and art by Tomoko Tanigiuchi, Kei Kobayashi, and Toga. Here’s a preview at The Pulse.

Fully a month after it showed up in bookstores, the sixth and penultimate volume of Satomi Ikezawa’s Othello (Del Rey) arrives at my local comic shop. I’ve really enjoyed this book and its unusual approach to standard shôjo crises, but seven volumes seems just the right length.

It’s not on this week’s shipping list, but my LCS seems to think that the second volume of Scott Chantler’s very entertaining Northwest Passage (Oni) will arrive on Wednesday. If so, yay! It’s a historical adventure with lots of action, detail, and beautiful art. (Here’s what I thought of the first chapter.)

Filed Under: Uncategorized

The (Shojo) Beat goes on

February 13, 2006 by David Welsh

There’s a lively discussion going on over at Love Manga on shôjo, anthologies, anime, and just how awesome Ai Yazawa is. Brigid from MangaBlog arrives to share the always welcome perspective of her shôjo-loving daughters, who enjoy both Shojo Beat the magazine and the subsequent collected versions of the serialized stories.

Speaking of Ai Yazawa and Shojo Beat, this week’s Flipped takes a look at Nana and Kamikaze Girls.

And speaking of great manga in general, several bloggers have noted that Viz is having a sale on some of its out-of-print titles, many of which are really, really terrific. There goes my tax refund.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Spare parts

February 12, 2006 by David Welsh

Is it weird that the movie that convinced me Scarlett Johansson is a really good actor is The Island? It’s a terrible movie, which is precisely what you’d expect from a Michael Bay remake of Parts: The Clonus Horror. And it isn’t like I haven’t enjoyed Johansson’s performances before in much better movies.

But she’s just so damned funny in The Island – intentionally funny, but logically so within Bay’s moronic framework. She seems to have hit that precise sweet spot where a fine and talented actor does something exactly right with really, really bad material.

Up until now, I’ve been led to believe her skill set ran exactly as far as sulking beautifully and with meaning. Now I know she’s capable of keen, satirical comedy, so capable that she can pull it off probably without the director’s knowledge or consent. I want to see her in a Christopher Guest movie, riffing with Parker Posey.

I do find myself trying to picture her reaction when her agent described the part to her. “You’ll be playing the clone of a supermodel.” Pause. “For Michael Bay.” I’m guessing such a moment would leave you with two choices: laugh or cry. I’m glad she laughed.

She’s pretty much all that The Island has going for it, and the movie makes me wonder why contemporary directors are so fond of remaking wonderfully terrible movies that can’t really be improved. There’s a Poseidon Adventure remake in production (just Poseidon now, which fills me with the direst of suspicions), and seriously, there is not a more perfect, unintentionally stupid movie than the original.

The thought of someone trying to turn that kind of material into something genuinely exciting and tense is just depressing. And without the kind of B-list actresses that the 1970s seemed to produce in such wonderful quantities (Stella Stevens, Pamela Sue Martin, Carol Lynley) to liven things up, the prospects become even direr. (The only contemporary actress I can think of that has something of the same quality of a Martin or a Lynley is Milla Jovovich, and she isn’t in Poseidon. Fools!)

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Slap and tickle

February 11, 2006 by David Welsh

In the wake of last week’s glib handling of the subject of gay lead characters in Marvel comics, Newsarama gives Joe Quesada the chance to say essentially the same thing all over again, but with a more conciliatory tone. He explains the rationale behind Slap Leather’s MAX designation:

“Rawhide was labeled MAX because the major hook and focus of the project was the sexuality of the main character, a 50-plus year old established character. The reason the books featuring the characters you named in your question [Northstar, Hulkling, Asguardian] don’t carry a MAX label is because that’s not the focus of their books. The sexuality aspect of their lives is just one part of the whole that makes up their books, as opposed to Rawhide, where the fact that he was gay and his history was the major point of the book.”

I should probably confess at this point that I kind of liked Slap Leather. It required a conscious decision on my part that the book’s single joke wasn’t sniggering at Rawhide Kid but at the characters around him, and I completely understand why everyone wouldn’t come to that conclusion. It took a fair amount of squinting for me to reach it, to be honest. That said, I never thought the title was in any way progressive, just mildly amusing in a faintly subversive way. (If you want a real laugh, take a look at this old Crossfire transcript where Stan Lee maintains that there’s no innuendo in Slap Leather. Stan, there’s nothing but innuendo in it.)

So Quesada complaining that Brokeback Mountain will get the credit for humanizing the gay cowboy while Slap Leather goes unrecognized is kind of like an adult video producer claiming that, hey, they’ve had gay cowboys in their films for years, and nobody ever gave them an Oscar.

And maybe Quesada’s approach isn’t all that conciliatory after all:

“So, while some may want to get up in arms three years later that it was labeled MAX, I don’t understand why we aren’t at least celebrating the fact that it happened, that it was published and we took on the naysayers and the hardcore fanmen and the letter writers and the bloodthirsty media. That was the true triumph of Rawhide. The book and the character now exist!”

I know, I know… comic publisher attempts to reframe the argument to serve his own ends, alert the media. Still, dusting off a mothballed property and gaying it up for laughs isn’t exactly a milestone of creative daring or social progress.

It’s not entirely clear, but it does seem like the Kid could get another stab at the spotlight without the MAX stamp:

“NRAMA: That all said, would you consider publishing a new Rawhide Kid story where his sexual identity wasn’t an issue/referred to…

“JQ: Yes.”

***

Also at Newsarama, a review of a Be Beautiful title in the latest Your Manga Minute introduces me to an unfamiliar bit of fan-speak, “non-con.” That’s about the cutest euphemism for “rape” that I’ve ever seen, and I really could have gone the rest of my life without learning of it.

***

And finally at Newsarama, there’s Brian Hibbs’s eagerly awaited look at 2005 BookScan figures in the latest installment of Tilting at Windmills. This gives me the perfect opportunity to point you to the back-in-action David Taylor, who discusses the column at Love Manga. Chris Butcher takes a thorough look at comics.212.net, too. I particularly like one of the points from Chris’s summary:

“I find it vaguely exciting as a comics retailer though, knowing that there’s still an obvious (and massive) gap to fill, where breadth of selection and product knowledge is more important than not.”

Filed Under: Uncategorized

From the stack: THE TICKING

February 9, 2006 by David Welsh

Did you ever come across one of those graphic novels that you admired tremendously but couldn’t quite decide if you liked? It’s a conundrum, because in the case of Reneé French’s The Ticking (Top Shelf Productions), whether or not I like it seems kind of trivial. I’m not even convinced that it wants to evoke that kind of simplistic response.

At the same time, it isn’t one of those books where you can smell the hunger for importance and weight. It isn’t some grabby, Oscar-bait comic, slathered with relevance and depth (though the marketing leans in that direction). It’s much more precise in its effect, and that effect is both familiar and unsettling.

It’s got the rhythms of a children’s book and something of the jarring tone of an early David Lynch film. But it isn’t comforting as the former or alienating as the latter. It occupies its own frank ground. French doesn’t really seem to want to disturb you too badly, but she doesn’t want to lie to you, either.

She follows the life of Edison Steelhead, a boy born with facial deformities. His mother dies during childbirth, and his father, Cal, moves with his son to an isolated island. Cal might be trying to protect Edison from the cruelty of other people, or he might just be caught up in his own pain and embarrassment, or maybe it’s a mixture of both.

Edison is thoughtful and observant, like French. He spends his days sketching mundane, even grotesque objects, not to beautify them but to record them and perhaps understand them. As Cal tries to conceal and alter Edison’s appearance, Edison becomes increasingly dedicated to accuracy (or honesty). He respects things as they are. (This even extends to the chimpanzee Cal brings home as a sort of sister for Edison. She understands things by eating them.)

The conflict between father and son is profound, but French never overstates it. She simply presents it with a weird kind of delicacy, using just a smattering of dialogue and narration. The emotional arc of the story, which is really all there is, seems to arrive in an almost off-handed way. There aren’t any flashes of naked despair or conventional uplift so much as captured moments that create a cumulative effect. It’s a fascinating approach, and it fuses perfectly with the visuals.

French’s illustrations straddle the line between endearing and bizarre. She looks unflinchingly at Edison’s disfigurement, though she almost discreetly averts here eyes from Cal’s pain. It’s a poignant visual representation of their different perspectives, the individual ways they’ve chosen to deal with life. She does lush, varied work with tones and shading. It adds depth and texture to the illustrations, grounding her odd, ugly characters in something almost normal.

I don’t think I’ve ever seen a graphic novel that was so much of a piece. Words and images are perfectly in balance with story and tone. Every element serves every other element in some interlocking way. At the same time, there are enough contradictions in the work that it doesn’t seem static or pat. It’s creepy and sweet, funny and haunting, honest and sad.

Looking over what I’ve just written, I think The Ticking isn’t really something you can simply like or dislike. It’s much more elemental than that.

(Thanks to Greg McElhatton for sharing his preview copy of the book.)

Filed Under: From the stack, Top Shelf

« Previous Page
Next Page »

Features

  • Fruits Basket MMF
  • Josei A to Z
  • License Requests
  • Seinen A to Z
  • Shôjo-Sunjeong A to Z
  • The Favorites Alphabet

Categories

Recent Posts

  • Hiatus
  • Upcoming 11/30/2011
  • Upcoming 11/23/2011
  • Undiscovered Ono
  • Re-flipped: not simple

Comics

  • 4thletter!
  • Comics Alliance
  • Comics Should Be Good
  • Comics Worth Reading
  • Comics-and-More
  • Comics212
  • comiXology
  • Fantastic Fangirls
  • Good Comics for Kids
  • I Love Rob Liefeld
  • Mighty God King
  • Neilalien
  • Panel Patter
  • Paul Gravett
  • Polite Dissent
  • Progressive Ruin
  • Read About Comics
  • Robot 6
  • The Comics Curmudgeon
  • The Comics Journal
  • The Comics Reporter
  • The Hub
  • The Secret of Wednesday's Haul
  • Warren Peace
  • Yet Another Comics Blog

Manga

  • A Case Suitable for Treatment
  • A Feminist Otaku
  • A Life in Panels
  • ABCBTom
  • About.Com on Manga
  • All About Manga
  • Comics Village
  • Experiments in Manga
  • Feh Yes Vintage Manga
  • Joy Kim
  • Kuriousity
  • Manga Out Loud
  • Manga Report
  • Manga Therapy
  • Manga Views
  • Manga Widget
  • Manga Worth Reading
  • Manga Xanadu
  • MangaBlog
  • Mecha Mecha Media
  • Ogiue Maniax
  • Okazu
  • Read All Manga
  • Reverse Thieves
  • Rocket Bomber
  • Same Hat!
  • Slightly Biased Manga
  • Soliloquy in Blue
  • The Manga Critic

Pop Culture

  • ArtsBeat
  • Monkey See
  • Postmodern Barney
  • Something Old, Nothing New

Publishers

  • AdHouse Books
  • Dark Horse Comics
  • Del Rey
  • Digital Manga
  • Drawn and Quarterly
  • Fanfare/Ponent Mon
  • Fantagraphics Books
  • First Second
  • Kodansha Comics USA
  • Last Gasp
  • NBM
  • Netcomics
  • Oni Press
  • SLG
  • Tokyopop
  • Top Shelf Productions
  • Vertical
  • Viz Media
  • Yen Press

Archives

Copyright © 2026 · Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in