The Manga Curmudgeon

Spending too much on comics, then talking too much about them

  • Home
  • About
  • One Piece MMF
  • Sexy Voice & Robo MMF
  • Comics links
  • Year 24 Group links

Obsession resumes

March 13, 2007 by David Welsh

I was reading Kate Culkin’s PWCW profile of the delightful Aya (Drawn & Quarterly), and I came to a screeching halt when I read this:

“The ALA has nominated the book as one of its 2008 Great Graphic Novels for Teens.”

What?! There’s a new round of nominations?! Why wasn’t I informed?! To the search engine!

Ahhhh, Young Adult Library Services Association… it’s been too long.

Anyway, it’s a nice first round of nominees with some personal favorites (After School Nightmare, Emma, Goong) and some books I’m looking forward to reading (The Plain Janes, The Tiny Tyrant).

Filed Under: Awards and lists, Comics in libraries, Linkblogging

Manga chic

March 13, 2007 by David Welsh

Manga Month may still be down the road a ways, but it seems like it’s Boutique Week on the ComicList, with welcome arrivals from smaller publishers.

Take the pick of the week, Fumiyo Kouno’s Town of Evening Calm, Country of Cherry Blossoms from Last Gasp. The U.S. publisher of Keiji Nakazawa’s legendary Barefoot Gen offers another perspective at Japan after the atomic bomb, and I’ve heard nothing but enthusiastic responses from people who’ve read it in scanlation or Japanese.

Fresh on the heels of MangaBlog’s interview with Stephen Robson, Fanfare/Ponent Mon releases the third volume of Times of Botchan, scripted by Natsuo Sekikawa and conceived and drawn by the superb Jiro (The Walking Man) Taniguchi, and re-offers Yukiko’s Spinach, written by Frédéric Boilet and drawn by the fabulous Kan (Kinderbook) Takahama.

Gullywasher offers Danica Novgorodoff’s Isotope Award-winning mini-comic, A Late Freeze, which I really enjoyed.

Okay, CMX is an arm of DC, so it’s not really boutique-y, but Kaoru Mori’s Emma feels boutique-y, and I’m holding on to this theme with my fingernails. The third volume ships on Wednesday, and it’s lovely.

And Blu offers Hirotaka Kisaragi’s Innocent Bird, which I bought over the weekend because it seemed like it would be enthusiastically tawdry but turned out to be sort of interesting and thoughtful instead. I liked it, but I can’t say I’m not a little bit disappointed by the smut shortage. Stupid plastic wrap.

Filed Under: Blu, CMX, ComicList, Fanfare/Ponent Mon, Last Gasp, Mini-comics

From the stack: Innocent Bird Vol. 1

March 13, 2007 by David Welsh

It’s delightful how easily the premise of Hirotaka Kisaragi’s Innocent Bird (Blu) translates into buddy-comedy bluster:

A devil trying to do the right thing… An angel upholding God’s law the only way he knows how… Genesis… was just… the beginning!

Inventing variations on bombastic movie trailers throughout my reading of this book probably led me to like it more than I should. It’s not especially gripping, and readers hoping for sexy blasphemy will be sorely disappointed, but Kisaragi does chart some interesting, even moving territory along the way.

Shirasagi is a very bad devil. He’s gone so far as to abandon his demonic duties to become a priest in a low-rent neighborhood, ministering to the downtrodden and teaching children mathematics and Japanese out of a shuttered nightclub. Karasu, the angel, cares more about the spirit of God’s law than the letter. When sent to convince Shirasagi to resume his duties as Beelzebub’s favorite sex toy, Karasu lacks the bureaucrat’s enthusiasm for order and regulation.

The two are essentially soldiers in a war that has become so codified as to be void of passion or meaning. Angels and devils do what they do because that’s what they’ve always done, and individual moral choice has been divorced from the equation. Shirasagi and Karasu are outsiders simply because they take a nuanced, personal view of their by-the-numbers circumstances. Even putting aside their mutual attraction, they’re dangerous because they think for themselves.

That conceit interests me, and it helps overcome a lot of the mundane mechanics of the story. Nothing particularly startling or even unexpected happens in terms of plot, and Kisaragi is much better at illustrating emotion than event. In spite of those shortcomings, Kisaragi has convinced me to want a happy outcome for her protagonists and to be curious about what happens to them next. (A sharply observed back-up story about building a family of choice goes a long way to sell me on Kisaragi’s abilities.)

Filed Under: Blu, From the stack

Weekend reading

March 12, 2007 by David Welsh

It was nice to have a weekend with plenty of time to plow through the pile of unread comics that had reached teetering heights and threatened to crush a cat should it tumble. (Okay, I didn’t improve the stack’s structural integrity or promote feline welfare by going out and buying more comics. Blame it on the convergence of a personal shopping day and sufficient intestinal fortitude to brave the mall.)

I’d read and really enjoyed the preview proof of Keiko Takemiya’s To Terra… (Vertical), and reading the entire first volume only confirmed my high opinion of it. Jog has a splendid critique of the book and articulates one element that will probably weigh heavily in the book’s success or failure with individual readers:

“But is it a good story? That might come down to whether the reader shares the author’s apparent feelings on what makes a story good. Much lip-service is paid to how Japanese comics tend to be more focused on character and journeys than American comics, which concentrate on events and destinations. To Terra… is the type of Japanese comic that embodies that old notion completely, far more so than something like, say, Death Note, which under the hood is nearly as plot-focused as Uncanny X-Men. And plot-focused readers may find this book to be nagging in its slow pace and its endless twirls of its favored themes, inching through what’s truthfully not a fresh premise.”

From my perspective, the moments of emotional evolution the characters experience do count as what you might call plot beats, so I found To Terra… to be a fairly brisk read. I do agree with JennyN that the book could really benefit from some text pieces on Takemiya and her pioneering peers in the Magnificent Forty-Niners, but I’m kind of greedy for that kind of stuff.

On the fluff front, I continue to be mindlessly entertained by Kiyoko Arai’s Beauty Pop (Viz – Shojo Beat), now in its third volume. In a world of manga protagonists who view achievement as essential to continued existence, Kiri’s bored indifference to competition and success is like a breath of fresh air.

On the “I agree” front, Greg McElhatton takes a look at the first four issues of Welcome to Tranquility (Wildstorm) and notices one weakness that threatens to undermine the book’s other strengths:

“The town itself as a setting stands out as being really fresh and different (despite the fact that towns of superpowered people have been done before) thanks to [writer Gail] Simone’s careful crafting of the social dynamic, but that same amount of care and meticulous creation doesn’t feel like it’s been extended to the actual cast of the book.”

I find that I’m forcibly pacing myself on reading the stories in Gilbert Hernandez’s Heartbreak Soup collection (Fantagraphics), just because I want to savor the individual chapters. The characters are great company, and I want to prolong the experience of getting to know them.

And in this week’s Flipped, I take the sad occasion of the conclusion of Love Roma (Del Rey) to look at the series that are still around to delight and amaze.

Filed Under: Flipped, Linkblogging

Stars search

March 11, 2007 by David Welsh

There’s some really solid work in Tokyopop’s Rising Stars of Manga People’s Choice competition. Some entries have lovely, accomplished art, and others have nicely crafted, imaginative scripts and stories. These are my five favorites, though:

Ares Maier by Daniel Lucas Cross: It’s great-looking and makes really good use of the short format. I particularly admire how well Cross pulled off the twist ending.

B is for Bishie by Margaux Hymel and Russell Herrick: Superb teamwork from Hymel and Herrick here, combining a perversely funny premise with pitch-perfect art. It got my vote.

Bloomfield Memory by Yujin Chung Moon: The premise is familiar, but Moon executes it with style, verve and sincerity, and the art is just breathtaking.

Minion by Alyssa Farris: Steam of consciousness and dream logic are difficult to evoke in a coherent narrative, but Farris seems to have just the artistic arsenal to pull it off.

The Cacti Boys by Sarah Adams and Christine Wu: Of all of the submissions that suggested a larger narrative, this is the one where I really want to know what happens next.

March 12 is the last day to vote.

Filed Under: Contests and giveaways, Tokyopop

Second look: Shazam! The Monster Society of Evil #2

March 11, 2007 by David Welsh

I had previously wondered about the price point and format of Jeff Smith’s Shazam! The Monster Society of Evil (DC). After reading the second issue, I find myself caring about that stuff a lot less, because the introduction Mary Marvel has rendered me incapable of thinking anything grown-up or grouchy. She’s a delight on every level.

So is the book. The pace has picked up over the first issue, which results in Smith doing more of the things he does so well in the same number of pages. I’d almost forgotten how deftly Smith can lampoon human nature. Since this is a kid’s power fantasy, it’s only appropriate that he opens the issue with laughably dumb, thoroughly recognizable grown-up behavior.

I hadn’t forgotten how well Smith is able to render and dialogue adventure sequences. They’re a mix of scary, funny and exciting, and they’re peppered with small, character-driven touches. The book is such a great merger of words and pictures.

And it’s nice to see a creator able to fold dark undertones into a story without allowing them to flavor the entire narrative. Billy and Mary have both faced some bleak circumstances, and Smith doesn’t shy away from the perils the kids have faced or their emotional consequences. But he doesn’t make those moments so explicit or maudlin that they overwhelm the bits of triumph and giddy fun. If anything, the darker bits enhance the lighter.

And Mary is really awesome. To quote her or describe her behavior in any detail would be to spoil the fun of watching it all unfold, so I won’t. But trust me: awesome.

Filed Under: DC

Selection

March 10, 2007 by David Welsh

There’s a lively round of compare-and-contrast going on over at MagaBlog over manga selections at Borders and Barnes & Noble outlets.

In the interest of science (and because I had a personal shopping day and didn’t feel like hauling myself up to Pittsburgh to go to the closest available Borders), I hit the Waldenbooks in the mall. While I prefer the shopping experience at the local Barnes & Noble (because it doesn’t induce claustrophobia and force me to go to the mall), I have to say that Waldenbooks has a much better manga selection.

It doesn’t have as many actual books, but it has more titles from a larger number of publishers. It positively stomps Barnes & Noble in terms of boys’ love and yaoi titles, carrying virtually everything Blu publishes and a fair amount from Kitty Media. It had more CMX and Dark Horse books than B&N and a competitive selection of stuff from Ice Kunion and Netcomics. And it had a copy of Red String, which I grabbed immediately because I’m curious about it and keep forgetting to tack it on to Amazon orders.

As far as other kids of graphic novels go, it’s pretty dire at Waldenbooks. I’m sure my memory is indulging in exaggeration, but all I remember seeing is a thin shelf of Marvel Ultimate titles.

Filed Under: Bookstores

Random Friday thoughts

March 9, 2007 by David Welsh

To show my age, I’m going to admit that reading the last volume of Minoru Toyoda’s Love Roma (Del Rey) gave me something of the same bittersweet feeling as watching the final episode of The Mary Tyler Moore Show.

*

I’ve always been suspect of the argument that it’s easier to get forgiveness than permission. This anecdote from Matt Thorn seems to confirm my suspicions.

*

Brigid’s interview with Fanfare’s Stephen Robson is illuminating, but all I could end up thinking was that my copy of Kan Takahama’s Awabi damned well better show up at my comic shop. I’m a short-sighted, selfish bastard.

*

If kids don’t love comics, they’re sure wasting a lot of energy pretending otherwise.

*

I don’t think attention automatically confers prestige. Sometimes attention is just a convergence of novelty, nostalgia and good timing. Here’s the teaser caption for the local college newspaper’s story on this week’s big spandex news: “Marvel Comics kills off one of its oldest superheroes in a political statement.”

*

I was reassured by my trip to the comic shop this week. When I was checking out, the clerk mentioned that she liked Welcome to Tranquility (Wildstorm) but would like it better if more attention was paid to the elderly characters instead of their angst-ridden heirs and well-intentioned caregivers. I thought that might have been an age-specific complaint, but she’s roughly the same age as the comic’s twenty-something whiners. In fairness, she might get her fill of self-styled outsider poseurs, given that she works at a comics shop in a college town, and not need any of the fictional variety.

We agreed that the driving mystery is pretty nifty, though.

*

False economy story problem: Is it worth coping with the aggravation of the local shopping mall to make use of my personal shopping day at Waldenbooks? I hate to admit it, but the store does have a more varied (if smaller) selection of titles than the local Barnes & Noble. And does navigating a sea of ‘tweens burn enough calories to justify consumption of a jalapeño pretzel?

*

The ground squirrel that lives around our house came out of hibernation just in time for the season’s first real blizzard. That seems like a metaphor for something.

Filed Under: Linkblogging

Flashback

March 8, 2007 by David Welsh

Does anyone else remember the series of Doonesbury strips where Duke died? And there were semi-serious obituaries in newspapers and people talking about the end of an era and stuff like that? And then it turned out that he’d just been zombified and placed in the service of an exiled Haitian dictator?

I love Doonesbury.

Filed Under: Comic strips

On the Rising

March 8, 2007 by David Welsh

Brigid has the details on Tokyopop’s seventh Rising Stars of Manga Competition, and there are some aspects of this year’s event that really jumped out at me.

“Eight winners will share equal prizes, taking the top spot in one of eight different genre-based categories: Action, Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, Romance or Sci-Fi.”

This strikes me as a terrific idea. All of these genres require different skill sets and showcase talents in unique ways, and it seems like it will give Tokyopop a chance to compare apples to apples. (And even among apples, there’s still tremendous variety. Pink Ladies! Grannies Smith! Golden Delicious!) It still must have been kind of mind-bending to categorize them, What if somebody submits a comedy-fantasy-romance? Or a horror-sci-fi-mystery? Maybe they should add an “Uncategorizable Fusion” genre next year.

It’s pretty amazing that the competition has grown to the point that they have enough submissions to present eight different $1,000 awards, plus $500 for the People’s Choice. Twenty-four finalists are vying for the People’s Choice prize, and you can view them and vote here.

Now I just have to overcome my archaic resistance to reading comics online to sample the contestants’ work.

Filed Under: Contests and giveaways, Linkblogging, Tokyopop

« Previous Page
Next Page »

Features

  • Fruits Basket MMF
  • Josei A to Z
  • License Requests
  • Seinen A to Z
  • Shôjo-Sunjeong A to Z
  • The Favorites Alphabet

Categories

Recent Posts

  • Hiatus
  • Upcoming 11/30/2011
  • Upcoming 11/23/2011
  • Undiscovered Ono
  • Re-flipped: not simple

Comics

  • 4thletter!
  • Comics Alliance
  • Comics Should Be Good
  • Comics Worth Reading
  • Comics-and-More
  • Comics212
  • comiXology
  • Fantastic Fangirls
  • Good Comics for Kids
  • I Love Rob Liefeld
  • Mighty God King
  • Neilalien
  • Panel Patter
  • Paul Gravett
  • Polite Dissent
  • Progressive Ruin
  • Read About Comics
  • Robot 6
  • The Comics Curmudgeon
  • The Comics Journal
  • The Comics Reporter
  • The Hub
  • The Secret of Wednesday's Haul
  • Warren Peace
  • Yet Another Comics Blog

Manga

  • A Case Suitable for Treatment
  • A Feminist Otaku
  • A Life in Panels
  • ABCBTom
  • About.Com on Manga
  • All About Manga
  • Comics Village
  • Experiments in Manga
  • Feh Yes Vintage Manga
  • Joy Kim
  • Kuriousity
  • Manga Out Loud
  • Manga Report
  • Manga Therapy
  • Manga Views
  • Manga Widget
  • Manga Worth Reading
  • Manga Xanadu
  • MangaBlog
  • Mecha Mecha Media
  • Ogiue Maniax
  • Okazu
  • Read All Manga
  • Reverse Thieves
  • Rocket Bomber
  • Same Hat!
  • Slightly Biased Manga
  • Soliloquy in Blue
  • The Manga Critic

Pop Culture

  • ArtsBeat
  • Monkey See
  • Postmodern Barney
  • Something Old, Nothing New

Publishers

  • AdHouse Books
  • Dark Horse Comics
  • Del Rey
  • Digital Manga
  • Drawn and Quarterly
  • Fanfare/Ponent Mon
  • Fantagraphics Books
  • First Second
  • Kodansha Comics USA
  • Last Gasp
  • NBM
  • Netcomics
  • Oni Press
  • SLG
  • Tokyopop
  • Top Shelf Productions
  • Vertical
  • Viz Media
  • Yen Press

Archives

Copyright © 2026 · Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in