The Manga Curmudgeon

Spending too much on comics, then talking too much about them

  • Home
  • About
  • One Piece MMF
  • Sexy Voice & Robo MMF
  • Comics links
  • Year 24 Group links
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / From the manga stack: Random thoughts

From the manga stack: Random thoughts

September 9, 2004 by David Welsh

It’s probably sacrilege, but Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind, by manga and anime legend Hayao Miyazaki, isn’t really working for me. I find the world Miyazki has created engaging, and the central premise is intriguing, but something is keeping me from connecting to it.

Part of it might be that I find the visual storytelling difficult to follow at times. More than once, I’ve found myself lost during an action sequence. That said, the images are often lovely when taken individually, and there’s a nice kinetic feeling, particularly when flight is depicted. But I’ve found the character designs to be a bit indistinct, too, which doesn’t help me track what’s happening.

I’m still enjoying Hot Gimmick, Miki Aihara’s tense, layered soap opera. I just finished reading volume six, and one thing that really struck me was Aihara’s ability to maintain a high level of drama even though the plot only moves incrementally forward. It’s not about big events or revelations so much as the cumulative effect of small moments, either from the present or buried in the past. (Johanna Draper Carlson just updated her Hot Gimmick page at Comics Worth Reading.)

Fake is still at the top of my list of guilty pleasures. As a police drama, it’s still a total wash. As a sexy, romantic adventure, I haven’t found anything to top it.

One thing disturbs me, though. Each volume (I’m up to the fifth) features a story about Carol and Bikky, teen-aged charges of hot cops Ryo and Dee. They’ve finally found some friends their own age, Lai and Lass. But Lai and Lass are crossover characters from another manga, Ra-1! The idea of crossover characters in manga is completely dischordant to me. Dear manga industry: please don’t do that. Love, David. (I kid. I think.)

Yu Watase continues to explore the power of words in her elegant, supernatural Alice 19th. I’ve heard a lot of good things about Watase’s latest work, Imadoki, where she forgoes mysticism for… horticulture? I’m game.

After disappointment (with Clamp School Detectives) and delight (Case Closed) with manga mysteries, I can’t wait to try Kindaichi Case Files. Johanna says it’s Manga Worth Reading, and that’s always a good predictor that I’ll enjoy it. And, hey, Greg McElhatton over at iComics likes it, too!

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Features

  • Fruits Basket MMF
  • Josei A to Z
  • License Requests
  • Seinen A to Z
  • Shôjo-Sunjeong A to Z
  • The Favorites Alphabet

Categories

Recent Posts

  • Hiatus
  • Upcoming 11/30/2011
  • Upcoming 11/23/2011
  • Undiscovered Ono
  • Re-flipped: not simple

Comics

  • 4thletter!
  • Comics Alliance
  • Comics Should Be Good
  • Comics Worth Reading
  • Comics-and-More
  • Comics212
  • comiXology
  • Fantastic Fangirls
  • Good Comics for Kids
  • I Love Rob Liefeld
  • Mighty God King
  • Neilalien
  • Panel Patter
  • Paul Gravett
  • Polite Dissent
  • Progressive Ruin
  • Read About Comics
  • Robot 6
  • The Comics Curmudgeon
  • The Comics Journal
  • The Comics Reporter
  • The Hub
  • The Secret of Wednesday's Haul
  • Warren Peace
  • Yet Another Comics Blog

Manga

  • A Case Suitable for Treatment
  • A Feminist Otaku
  • A Life in Panels
  • ABCBTom
  • About.Com on Manga
  • All About Manga
  • Comics Village
  • Experiments in Manga
  • Feh Yes Vintage Manga
  • Joy Kim
  • Kuriousity
  • Manga Out Loud
  • Manga Report
  • Manga Therapy
  • Manga Views
  • Manga Widget
  • Manga Worth Reading
  • Manga Xanadu
  • MangaBlog
  • Mecha Mecha Media
  • Ogiue Maniax
  • Okazu
  • Read All Manga
  • Reverse Thieves
  • Rocket Bomber
  • Same Hat!
  • Slightly Biased Manga
  • Soliloquy in Blue
  • The Manga Critic

Pop Culture

  • ArtsBeat
  • Monkey See
  • Postmodern Barney
  • Something Old, Nothing New

Publishers

  • AdHouse Books
  • Dark Horse Comics
  • Del Rey
  • Digital Manga
  • Drawn and Quarterly
  • Fanfare/Ponent Mon
  • Fantagraphics Books
  • First Second
  • Kodansha Comics USA
  • Last Gasp
  • NBM
  • Netcomics
  • Oni Press
  • SLG
  • Tokyopop
  • Top Shelf Productions
  • Vertical
  • Viz Media
  • Yen Press

Archives

Copyright © 2026 · Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in