Feedback on IDENTITY CRISIS keeps rolling in, notably from Don MacPherson and Randy Lander at The Fourth Rail.
Randy gives issue two a score of 1 out of a possible 10. Here’s why:
“When you’re working in a shared universe, you have a responsibility to think beyond just the shock moment, and Meltzer hasn’t done that. I find it ironic that in the same week DC publishes one of the one-shots celebrating the imagination and fun that Julius Schwartz brought to DC, including a story that features Ralph and Sue Dibny, they are also publishing a series that literally rapes the characters.”Don gives it a 7 out of 10, but expresses concern about accessability to new readers. What doe Don think IC has going for it?
“Meltzer’s script is a strong one as it breathes real emotion into longtime characters.”
Don also believes that longtime “DC super-hero fans are bound to be thrilled with Meltzer’s efforts.” That sound you just heard is George Grattan’s head exploding.
Other newsgroup posters have offered their views on the subject. And Graeme is monitoring the rampageous fanboys over at his delightful blog. Three words: “dildo of peace.”